Lucoli

"The pizza was great, however the service was terrible. I didn’t catch her name but she was rude about basically everything. For example, I asked her if I could add pepperoni to my pizza and her response was that I could order somewhere else, not with her and to do that next time. In addition to the condescending tone she spoke in, she still did not answer my question. The food was good, but the service was bad enough to ruin the experience. Very disappointing."

"I spotted this hidden gem from the road. It’s tucked behind things and I’d never noticed it. The place is tiny - takeout only I believe - but magical. The ovens are from another world. The mushroom pizza was unique and wonderful. The young women making the pizzas were charming and seem both good and committed to it. Can’t wait to explore further."

"Homemade everything here. Don't believe anything except 5 stars when it comes to Lucoli. We searched this place out through the Onebite app. I showed up before my order was supposed to be ready and I watched my order from start to finish. Maybe 5 min tops from the time they started prepping to sliced in the box. Go inside and meet the owner. Super nice guy.See the homemade ingredients and the massive oven yourself. Worth every penny. If you have to drive a little farther it's well worth it. I would love to have a pizza even remotely close this in NC. Guess we'll have to settle for enjoying this treat when we visit NY."

"We went into this place and it seemed more Authentic than most pizza places. It was being run by an Italian man and it smelled wonderful. Service was great and thats the only reason for 2 stars. Burnt broccoli and pesto that tastes like sour cream or too much lemon. The crust looks like it should be crispy, but it was so soggy. We paid $34 for this. We won't be back."

"This place is an absolute gem ! We like to drive around and try different pizzas, especially over the past year of take out during the pandemic. SO happy to have found this one. We would rate them TEN stars if we could. Everything made fresh and onsite. HIGHLY recommend Lucoli Pizza in Red Hook, worth the drive from anywhere in the Hudson Valley. We certainly will return."