Peggy’s Sweet & Savory (formerly Back In the Kitchen 3312 New York 343, Amenia, NY 12501

"First time customer. Ordered a red velvet cake for girlfriend’s bday - easily one of best red velvet cakes I’ve had. Peggy was responsive over email and easy to order from. This is my new spot, look forward to going back to try homemade baked goods and ordering cakes for special occasions going forward."

"This is such a lovely little gem in Amenia, NY. From the cookies to the scones and sandwiches! You can easily find something to enjoy!"

"What a great hole in the wall! You might miss the ground-level front door under the metal fire-escape steps if there weren't some regulars sipping cappucinos at the one sidewalk table to point the door out to you. Once you step in, it's cozy as a cave. And it smells like the kitchen of that aunt you have who cooks better than your mother. It's all your favorites your mother makes you, just somehow much better looking, smelling, and tasting. So, Peggy's offerings are at once ordinary and extraordinary, but in a homey rather than bougie way. Why is that strawberry rubharb muffin so deliciious? What's so good about this egg sandwich? God, I wish they hadn't run out of that frittata. Next time!"

"My notoriously hard to please seven-year-old exclaimed: "I LOVE this grilled cheese sandwich". High praise indeed. Also, wide variety of coffee options."