Main Street Pizza Cafe

"Whenever I'm on the island, I stop in for a Sicilian here. One of the best in the area. Gabe and his crew always make a great pizza."

"I’ve been to a ton of pizza places on Long Island and this place has always been consistently great! Great flavor, not too greasy, nice crisp with a good bend, etc. Also, every place does their own Buffalo Chicken slice but these guys seemed to have figured out the balance. If Barstool Sports showed up to this place and got a regular slice, I’d think they’d give them a high rating!"

"The pizza is pretty good. I’ve made it my regular go to. Prices are better than others in neighborhood."

"I use to come here years ago when I lived in kings park. Loved everything. Haven’t been back in 8 years. Came back and have noticed a huge change. Not as clean as it was. Which it’s not a deal breaker. What was .. was the pin wheel cold and raw. The middle wasn’t even semi cooked. It was cold and as raw as it can get. Sad to see one of my favorite pizza spots not keeping up with the quality they had prior. Slices were great though"

"Went there right after school with some friends and the workers were very nice. The food was fantastic.i got just to slices of plain pizza, and my friends got an egg plant parmesan, two some pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. They had enjoyed the food as well. Can't wait to go again"