Gunther Toody's Diner

"Gunther Toody's diner has a theme that is hard to miss. The restaurant is reminiscent of another time, a time when women wore poodle skirts with bobby sock, men wore leather jackets over white t-shirts, Elvis was gyrating on The Ed Sullivan Show and the juke box was where you met your sweetheart to pick a record. The dishes are named in homage to stars of old such as Johnny Cash chicken sandwich, Big Bopper and Grace Kelly breakfasts and burgers with names like Ernest Hemingway, John Wayne and Jackie Gleason. It was a little disappointing not to have Marilyn Monroe, Lucille Ball, Liz Taylor, or Doris Day represented on the menu, but maybe the kitchen is working on new items. The atmosphere was fun with posters, humorous plaques, and 2 antique motorcycles as center pieces. I knocked off 2 stars for cleanliness. The plastic menu covers were sticky, the table top juke boxes had dried condiments drippings, and the floors were littered with bits of food and other random debris. Our server, Ms. Robinson was a delight. She was working hard and having fun doing it. We shared an orange dream shake, and she put it into two glasses for us. We ordered burgers that were scrumptious. Cooked to perfection with generous portions of toppings and thick bacon that had to be folded to fit the bun. The fries were tasty. I had mac n cheese that was a tad dry for my liking. The menu was a treasure trove of American fare, and we are definitely going back to try more."

"Me and my boyfriend came here and amazing service and food, Mrs. Robinson was our server and she was very lovely. The food tasted great as well. My boyfriend got the John Wayne burger and I got the Ernest Hemingway burger."

"Our server Pee Wee was amazing. She had great customer service, gave a great recommendation as to what I should eat (Breakfast quesadilla). The food wasn’t the greatest but the service made it worth the visit. I will most definitely be back to try something new and different."

"Very fun place to take my 8 year old grandson. The food was fine. Our waitress Bobby Jo was terrific! She told us about all the deals so we know kids eat free on Mondays and you get a second burger for a $1.00 on Wednesdays & if you wear an ugly Christmas sweater you get a BOGO meal. And we bought a gift card & got 20% off! She also told us Gunther Toody history - it’s based on “Car 54 Where Are You?” And she was fun! Dressed up like a Christmas Tree!"

"I love a good old school diner! It had the jukebox and all. I’ve always passed Gunther toodys but never stopped in. My son had an appointment so we decided to stop. And OMG I do not regret it one bit. I had the most amazing and flavorful burger I’ve ever had called the John Wayne burger, talk about mouth watering. The Chile relleno on top was so crisp and the cheeses just oozed out. Must try. My son got the Ernest Hemingway burger and said he will be going back as much as he can possibly get there to have one of those burgers so to say we are satisfied is an understatement. Matter fact we came back in about a week later for the same order because it was that good!! Definitely recommend. The milkshakes are amazing as well. I had root beer and my son had a banana one and they were both great. Lots of flavor but not too much. Perfect cream to it so it was easy to drink down while not being melted down! Highly recommend! 9/10 for sure."