Hinkle's Sandwich Shop

"The layout of this place is bizarre. The side that has counter seating has no indoor access to the restroom. Patrons were literally going in and out, in the snow, to use the restroom. The burgers are sliders, you will need more than one. Other than the size, they were tasty. The piece of white fish was so crispy and covered the open-faced bun. The tartar sauce was delicious, I really enjoyed this sandwich. Another bizarre fact is that our food was not all delivered to the table at the same time. I received my potato salad, which I get, salads are usually delivered first, but then the fries and tater tots then about 5 minutes later my fish sandwich and then it was another 4-5 minutes before my fiance got his tiny burger. All the other food was getting cold by then from the door opening so much for people to either arrive or use the bathroom and return to the other side of the restaurant. I wish I could remember our waitresses name, she was a super sweet and bubbly young lady and was very attentive to all her tables. We were there on Friday 2/16."

"This place is a staple in Madison and has been in the same location since 1933. Located in downtown madison, this quaint gem has street parking, delicious food, and an atmosphere that is nostalgic and welcoming. As soon as we parked (half a block away) and got out of the car, we were hit with an aroma that they should bottle up and sell as a candle. Instantly took me back to a time that was much simpler. The hubs and i decided to sit on the bar side(there are 2 entrances to this slice of heaven, 1 being a bar only with about 10 stools and the other being a regular diner.) And our experience was good. We walked in and were greeted by the person behind the counter. She was wearing a smile and was very nice. We ordered and were able to watch the burgers being cooked. I had a double cheeseburger with tots, and hubs got 2 doubles and onion rings. The burgers are a little bit bigger than a white castle but are still considered sliders. They're Smashed and cooked with grilled onions. It takes longer for them to cook than it takes to eat, but they are so worth it! If you're traveling around Madison and want a quick, cheap, delicious smash burger slider, then please give this place a chance! You won't regret it, and your taste buds will thank you!!!"

"Have you ever just wanted something simple, good, and hits the spot just right? Well, if your answer is yes, then look no further. Go to Hinkle's Sandwich Shop. Don't sleep on this little sandwich joint serving up some great all-American, perfectly greasy, and simply delicious burgers (among other classics). We got three double cheese burgers, and it's been hours since we ate... I'm still thinking about them. Great service and laid back atmosphere. We really enjoyed this place."

"A Madison tradition long before the town became a tourist haven, Hinkle's is like a lighter version of an old-fashioned diner. There are two main rooms, one cafe-like with small tables and chairs, the other a diner with only stools at a long counter, from which you can see the Grill Cook at work. The burgers are medium-size sliders that are only a little greasy, but full of flavor. They asked if I wanted onions and I'm glad I said yes: they grill them with the patties, which really flavors the meat nicely. They have other kinds of sandwiches but WHY? I had a cup of the chili that was very good, lots of meat and nicely seasoned. I haven't tried any of their milkshakes yet, but they're famous for them. The service was fast and friendly, too. All that, and for a really reasonable price, what's not to like?!"