Papi's Pizza 111 West Columbia Street, Fort Wayne, IN 46802

"Got a square pizza and it was undercooked and somewhat soggy. For 30+ dollars you think you’d get a more firm and crispy crust. Plus the ranch is over a dollar for a tiny cup. I’d understand the steep prices if the food was better but it’s kind of a let down for the cost."

"First & Foremost: Extremely friendly staff, top tier. To start I made the mistake of getting the Tomato-Tony because I apparently suck at reading and interpreted bruschetta as prosciutto. So unfortunately I had to scrape off all the tomato, but I was really delighted with the mangled result, having a lot of pesto flavor still on the cheese. I wouldn’t order this one again due to preference, but it was still very good. While I am not a huge fan of thicker crusts, the Sicilian pepperoni was the best I’ve had in a long time, but it would have been amazing on the thin crust. Definitely will be back at some point soon, especially given the great location. Suggestions: (1) Having a display case for slices, it’s a nice feature that way you know what’s available. (2) A thin crust pepperoni or meat lovers available by the slice."

"The pizza was simply phenomenal. The crust had the perfect balance of chewiness and crispiness, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Each bite was a delightful explosion of taste in my mouth. Friendly staff, delicious food, and charming ambiance. I would highly recommend this restaurant to all pizza lovers!. 5 stars all around!"

"Truly an amazing place. 5/5 atmosphere. 80s/90s themed (including music). Staff were very kind and attentive. Prices are super fair for the quality. Pizza was fantastic. The crust was nice and chewy but also well-charred. Will absolutely be back. Just to make this seem like a fair review, I will say, it was quite hot in there because of the pizza oven and the furnace being on. However, as soon as I sunk my teeth into the Meat Me OTL pizza, I no longer cared about what the thermostat said."