Mr Gatti's Pizza

"I have not met a more hard working person than the manager named Hillary. She was doing the jobs for 3 employees. She is definitely a diamond in the house. I hope that She is recognized for all the hard work."

"I was quite impressed with thisl ocation!! The food was overall meh, but the salad bar was exceptional! The game area was really great! They had VR that my son loved, bowling, and even a little teacup ride! The manager/main person on staff was so friendly, helpful, and and kind. He gave my kids toys out of the treasure box when they hadn't earned enough tickets to buy a prize. We will definitely make this a regular stop when we drive through the area."

"My wife and I took our Grand Daughter here on Friday 12-1-2023. We were greeted by a very friendly daytime Manager. He was very professional with us and his employees. They were all decorating for Christmas and doing a nice job. The food was good. This is one of our Grand Daughters favorite places, she can eat and play fun games. We will return when in Evansville. We just wanted to let you know that we were pleased with our visit. Thank You, Jon Willis."

"This is the first time going and was rather disappointed. I gave it 4 stars solely on the fact they had bumper cars, small bowling, and the ride similar to the liberty launch at Holiday World. It was a saturday night and was busy, but what lines there was, moved at a decent pace. The food was decent. Its a self bus place, at least for now, however when we went to get more food, someone cleared our table and drink cups so we no longer had cups. The game room was the biggest disappointment. Figuring how big Evansville is and the amount of people, I was expecting it to be larger. They had some good games to play, but overall the amount of games compared to people was disappointing. Walked around in circles alot waiting to play games, if others didnt cut, or figure out what to play again. Numerous games were down. The game card didn't want to register on half the games we attempted to play. Came with the expectation to stay for an hour or two, left after about 40 or so minutes, including time to eat. Probably won't be back, and if so only for the food."

"This review is based on a dine in experience with the buffet. What was once a pretty common chain of pizza restaurants Mr.Gattis is always a stop when I find one. Unfortunately many are gone now, and honestly I don't know why. This particular restaurant had a feeling of general "need of cleaning". Tables were somewhat clean, as were the plates for the buffet. Only Coke products on hand for drinks. Buffet and salad bar were well stocked. The pizza undercarriage was not crisp, rather chewy instead. The dough has great flavor. The sauce is deep red, spread evenly across the pizza. Sauce had great tomato flavor as well. The cheese was slightly greasy, and also had a great flavor. The crust had a very nice snap. Being that it was a buffet, I tried many pieces. They have an entire section of specialty pizzas as well including a wonderful Buffalo Chicken. This pizza has a unique flavor. One that most seem to really enjoy. I am one of those people. I would definitely recommend this pizza place. Well stocked buffet and salad bar. Dessert pizzas as well. And kids seem to love the game room."