J&J's Pizza Shack 1454 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46385

"I am deleting my old review as my latest experience was not positive. I do appreciate the coupon for $3 off. I ordered an XL cheese with half mushrooms. When the pizza was delivered I was frustrated that I was charged 8.20 for mushrooms and there wasn't many there. Not enough to cover half the pizza. It's not right to charge that much money for half a pizza. If it is only on half the pizza customers should pay half the cost. The only recourse was to drive to the restaurant and return the pizza for it to be remade. The manager was professional but not really kind and it told me to just deal with it for who knows if my pizza would have been tampered with. My friend passed in the morning and all I wanted was to not cook and get pizza. So, I have chosen to not order anymore as there are always issues. Of course, I do appreciate it the delivery driver and the hard work of the food service industry."

"My piece was cold and I talked to the manager and he Pretty much oh well. I will never order pizza There Again The Manager was ignorant. I was getting pizza there for 20 years. No more I hope the owner See this post,"

"We've been ordering here for years now, best tasting and most economical pizza place in town, hands down. Sometimes we pre-order for a specific time and it's always there within a few minutes and just out of the oven hot! Drivers are always friendly. We've actually turned a few of the neighbors on to it! Can't say enough!!! Keep it up! ❤️"

"delicious!! wish we lived closer but my boyfriend and I traveled from Ohio for a concert and wanted pizza while we were in town. top 5 pizza place ever for sure. we had a deep dish supreme. came with a free 2 liter by surprise! love. workers were also very friendly. thank you:)"

"Their stuffed crust kitchen sink is my ALL time favorite pizza! I live about 2 hours away so every time I get up that way I gotta grab a pizza."