Amelio's Pizzeria 115 South Ohio Avenue, Sidney, OH 45365

"Almost $60 for burnt pizza. Smashed cake on the bar. Door was locked at 8:30 when they close at 9:00. Our pizza was takeout. Ordered ahead of time so it's not like they didn't know they'd have customers."

"Went in on a busy Friday night and I was impressed with how well the employees worked together to take care of customers. The restaurant looked great and was clean. I got The Big Four pizza and it came out perfect, I could see from where I was sitting that the kitchen staff was working hard. I'll be back soon."

"Tried the a few months ago, place was busy and service was not good. Understood from the busy night and understaffing. Tried again tonight. Ordered takeout. Pizza, garlic knots, and salad. Was told 30 minutes. Food didn’t come out until 1:10 minutes after I ordered. Two different waitstaff told me it was almost ready during my 45 minute in house wait. Dine in was not busy. Gave me the food, and I had to remind them I didn’t pay. Took 15% off the bill for more than doubling my wait. Sad, because we enjoy the pizza and salad but do not think we will be back."

"Nice little Italian restaurant in downtown Sidney, OH. Really enjoyed my meal and drinks. The server was super sweet & caring. Went on a Tuesday night and the place wasn’t crowded. So there was plenty of parking space right outside. If you come at night, the door will likely be locked: make sure to knock go get someone’s attention or else you’ll miss their delicious meals. Overall, loved the place. Will definitely stop by whenever I’m in town :)"

"Awesome old world Italian food! Great atmosphere with an old meets new cozy kind of vibe. They make their own marinara and it shows. Homemade pizza crust with fresh toppings. Freshly cut mozzarella wrapped in a wonton wrapper and fried is their new take on a boring old cheese stick, and it is good! Especially when dipped in some leftover garlic sauce from the homemade garlic knots! Toni (the owner) is a sweetheart and the pride she takes in her family heritage shows."