Hunter & Thief

"What a hidden gem! Absolutely loooved the super relaxed vibe and openness of the place. Jonathan, has such a charming and welcoming personality and gave us ample adv and space and time to just enjoy the place, the decor, the music, and the outstanding food. We had the kale caesar salad, the hummus and fish and chips. All just absolutely exquisite! Only suggestion to replace is the bread w the hummus. The bread was too dry and crumbled too easy to use with the amazing hummus. I would probably serve it with either celery sticks OR pita OR potato chips. Will definitely go back soon !"

"Had girls night here, and we all loved the place. The floating candles and dark walls give it a cool moody vibe. They also had a photobooth which is fun. The bar is pretty long for a small space. We were drawn here for the craft cocktails and those were great too. We started with the ricotta toast which had a little kick to it but very good. I had the arugula salad special and added the grilled chicken - and it was amazing! My friends had the fried chicken sandwich and the fish & chips. I hope they expand the menu in the future because the options were limited if you're coming to eat. The only thing that was disappointing was that they were out of a few items - like some food and they were out of the wine that we wanted to have. But overall we all said that it was a really nice spot, and we'll be back with our partners for date night!"

"I was referred to this spot by some fellow buddies of mine and my brother who is very picky about where he has his cocktails at so on date night we started here and yes I was very impressed,great for date night or friends night out interior decor was very nice bartenders were very welcoming and very knowledgeable about the menu will definitely be returning here"

"A must stop! Really enjoyed the vibe, cocktails are very good, food is fresh and my burger was amazing. My sister is steadfast in her desires and didn't like her drink and they re-did it perfectly. Will definitely be back again for a date night."

"The new standard for cocktail bars on Long Island. Hunter and Thief boasts a well curated, seasonal, and evolving cocktail and food menu. Do NOT sleep on the food selection - everything from the ricotta toast, burger, house cut fries and chips, sour cream and onion dip, and kale caesar were amazing. The cocktails are some of the best available on Long Island & the beer list is currently exclusively Cantina Cantina(!). The staff is extremely knowledgable and friendly and make every trip to H&T even more memorable than the last. Every detail of the space was well planned out and fun (check out the take one/leave one nook by the bathrooms!). Lindenhurst is lucky to have this place, and I look forward to tasting through the evolving menu. Cheers!"