Picasso's Pizza 5413 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

"We usually drive back to Buffalo twice a year for Bills games. We get an Airbnb and load up on pizza and wings. This is absolutely my favorite pizza. We get the "Kitchen Sink" party pizza and eat on it for days. Wings are great, too. Staff and ownership are friendly."

"I sent $30 on his sandwich was supposed to be chicken finger sub and what a mess. Disgusting. I can’t believe they sell food like this overpriced and you can’t even eat it. This is terrible. Do not go there. You’ll be wasting your money and spending way too much for nothing."

"My father-in-law came home with pizza and to our surprise, we see a missing piece of pizza. Hopefully, the owner gives the employees a lunch break so they don’t have to steal customers food!!! Never going back! We demand a full refund, free pizza and an APOLOGY!!!"

"Picasso’s delivered an ideal pie for lunch today. That cup n’ char pepperoni is my favorite. They even use fresh mushrooms! Super friendly staff, prompt delivery, pizza spent enough time in the oven. Awesome!"

"I ordered a 1/2 M steak pizza, which was delicious and beautifully made. The Large 1/2 cheese and 1/2 with vegetables wasn’t. The dough wasn’t fully cooked on either side with the side with the veggies more raw. I decided to throw it in the oven for a bit after I called to let them know. Even after the it was still the worst pizza ever and I have had their pizza plenty of times. I don’t like complaining as I didn’t request a refund, I also tipped but for almost $60 I expect to be able to eat what I ordered. I had to throw it out and ended up spending another $75 to make sure everyone ate. Pic is of after I threw it in the oven and still wasn’t able to fix the issue"