Nicolosi's Pizzeria and Restaurant

"Tonight I went in with a request for a pizza that was unusual lol and a pizza they don't even make on their menu! But not only did they make it but it was amazing! This is one of my favorite pizzerias to go to! (It was a California chicken pizza BTW lol) and the decorations are awesome always have a blast!"

"This place has never given me any problems. They never screw up their food. The service is quick and easy. We love their buffalo chicken cheesesteaks and pierogies. The fries don’t have much flavor but everything else we’ve had is nothing to complain about. By the way at first when I saw the scary decorations I thought Nicolosi’s just never took them down from Halloween but after seeing the zombie on the front of their menu in person, I figured out that it’s just something they do. Just look at the other pictures of the interior! If you have kids and they scare easy, I wouldn’t recommend bringing them in, and this is nothing against Nicolosi’s. If anything, it’s refreshing to see a local pizza place doing something like this! I don’t know what other people think of it, but as a consumer I say props to them."

"Hands down, this pizza is the absolute best pizza in the tri-state area. Let's face it, this tri-state is where you come for pizza so this is quite possibly the best pizza worldwide. A family owned business that takes pride in quality and community. This place is a unique gem. If you're not getting your pizza fix here you are seriously missing out. Stop in, order a pie, chat with the staff, check out the cool decor, take a bite and enjoy the taste.... damn it's good!"

"Jay takes pride in his establishment, as he should. The food was absolutely delicious. Everything, pizza, steak sandwiches, sauce, and customer service. The wonderful person who took my order, (I wish I knew her name) She repeated the entire order, I even made some changes and she didn't mind at all. Very accommodating. It was well worth the 25 minute drive. This family will definitely continue to patronize this awesome family owned restaurante . Thank you Jay, delicious!"

"The grandma pie is so delicious (pictured with sausage, peppers and onions) - the sauce and crust are fantastic! Friendly service and fun horror movie themed decor (although we discovered Grubhub will deliver!) Highly recommend!"