Villa Italia Ristorante

"Absolutely in love with this local gem! My wife and I stumbled upon this restaurant recently, despite having passed it countless times before, and it has quickly become our go-to spot. We've been frequenting it weekly for the last three months, and each visit has been nothing short of delightful. The staff have become more like friends to us, greeting us with such warmth and hospitality every time we walk in. The food is simply amazing – every dish is a hit, and the prices are unbelievably affordable. It's rare to find a place that feels like home while offering exceptional cuisine at great value. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a new favorite spot!"

"Okay, what the heck was this? Is it a pizza place or a high end Italian place wannabe? The decor is straight out of the late 1990’s. I was excited when I saw a cloth napkins, but then quickly realized they were sitting on a diner style paper place mat. The silverware is cheap, as well. That’s all fine for a pizza place, but you shouldn’t pay $30 for an entree in a place like this. EVERY THING is breaded. I ordered the butterfly pork chops…. breaded. At least they gave you freshly sauteed vegetables. The salad comes in a little bowl with two stale tasting olives and croutons from a box with salad dressing in a cheap “to-go” plastic container placed in the salad bowl. The salad plates and soup bowls stayed on the table the entire meal, they were never cleared for the entrees. The bread comes with cheap butter in a plastic container that you have to peal off the foil on top. However, the bread was warm. Do you see why I’m confused? Don’t order the fish, the gnocci was decent, and DO NOT ORDER WINE. We had two different types and they were both terrible. We’ve driven by this place for 8 years, it always seemed like a decently busy parking lot so we brought our family of 5 for dinner. $187 before tip for a pretty mediocre meal and service. Although, the wait staff were very nice and hustling. The place is filled with old people or young people with crying babies. Just know what you’re getting. I am a bit sorry to slam the place but I really just don’t get it."

"My husband had yummy spaghetti. I ordered a cold antipasto, it was more like a mini chef's salad, mostly iceberg lettuce."

"I stayed in the Newburgh area for two nights to attend a convention. I passed Villa Italia on my way back to Newburgh KOA. I decided to stop for takeout pizza. I ordered a six slice meat lovers. Absolutely delicious. I waited only 15 minutes. It was fresh, hot and very appetizing. The staff was courteous. I encourage you to go out of your way for this one."