TOP 10 Best Unique accommodations in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

The Liberty Lodge at Sister Bay is a charming lodging establishment located at 11034 Wisconsin 42, in the picturesque town of Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This cozy retreat offers comfortable accommodations and a warm, welcoming atmosphere for guests looking to unwind and relax in the heart of Door County. With its convenient location near local attractions, shops, and restaurants, The Liberty Lodge is the perfect home base for exploring all that this beautiful area has to offer. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a weekend escape with friends, The Liberty Lodge at Sister Bay is the ideal destination for your next trip.

The Yacht Club at Sister Bay is a luxurious lodging institution located at 10673 Regatta Way in the charming town of Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States. Nestled along the beautiful shores of Lake Michigan, this upscale establishment offers guests a unique and unforgettable experience in a stunning waterfront setting. With elegant accommodations, top-notch amenities, and personalized service, The Yacht Club at Sister Bay is the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway or special event. Whether you're looking to unwind in style or explore the natural beauty of Door County, this premier institution is sure to exceed your expectations.

The Sister Bay Getaway is a charming lodging located at 2373 Parkview Drive in the picturesque town of Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This cozy retreat offers a peaceful and relaxing atmosphere for guests looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. With comfortable accommodations and friendly staff, The Sister Bay Getaway is the perfect destination for a weekend getaway or a longer vacation. Explore the beauty of Door County and make unforgettable memories at this lovely institution.

Open Hearth Lodge is a charming lodging establishment located at 2669 South Bay Shore Drive in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States. Situated in the heart of Door County, this cozy lodge offers comfortable accommodations and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms, modern amenities, and beautiful views of the surrounding countryside. Whether you're looking for a relaxing getaway or a fun-filled vacation, Open Hearth Lodge is the perfect destination for your next trip to Wisconsin.

The Dörr Hotel is a modern Nordic-inspired lodging located at 2329 Mill Road in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States. Inspired by the Scandinavian history of Door County, the hotel offers a year-round experience that combines contemporary design with local charm. Situated in the heart of Sister Bay, The Dörr Hotel serves as a gateway for guests to connect with the seasons and the community. Whether you're enjoying a summer evening on the patio or exploring the winter landscape with snowshoe rentals, the hotel aims to provide a unique Door County adventure for every guest.

Located at 2322 Mill Road in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, Goose & Twigs is a charming lodging institution that offers a cozy and comfortable stay for visitors. The picturesque surroundings and peaceful atmosphere make it the perfect retreat for those looking to relax and unwind. The rooms are tastefully decorated and equipped with modern amenities to ensure a pleasant stay. Whether you are visiting for a weekend getaway or a longer vacation, Goose & Twigs provides a welcoming and hospitable environment for all guests. Experience the beauty of Wisconsin at this lovely institution in Sister Bay.

Located in the heart of downtown Sister Bay, Wisconsin, the DownTown Inn is a charming and affordable lodging option. Situated on an acre of scenic landscape, this family-owned hotel offers nineteen cozy and ultra-clean rooms in six buildings. Each room is spacious and comfortably furnished, with amenities such as free WiFi, flat screen TVs, mini fridges, and coffee makers. The Inn is surrounded by charming gardens and wooded areas, providing a peaceful retreat while still being close to the action. Within walking distance, guests can explore a variety of unique shops, galleries, restaurants, the village marina, and a sandy beach. Whether you're looking to relax or explore the vibrant surroundings, the DownTown Inn is the perfect place to stay in Sister Bay.

The Coachlite Inn is a charming lodging establishment located at 2544 South Bay Shore Drive in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This cozy inn offers a comfortable and inviting atmosphere for guests to relax and unwind during their stay in the beautiful Door County region. With a convenient location near the bay and a variety of amenities, including spacious rooms, complimentary breakfast, and friendly staff, The Coachlite Inn is the perfect choice for a peaceful retreat in the heart of Wisconsin. Whether you are visiting for a romantic getaway or a family vacation, you are sure to enjoy your stay at this lovely inn.

The Wooden Heart Inn is a charming lodging establishment located at 11086 Wisconsin 42 in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This cozy inn offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a relaxing getaway in the heart of Door County. With comfortable accommodations and friendly staff, guests can enjoy a peaceful retreat surrounded by the beauty of the Wisconsin countryside. Whether you're looking for a romantic escape or a family vacation, the Wooden Heart Inn is the perfect destination for your next trip.

SwedeInn is a charming lodging institution located at 10631 Bluffside Road in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. Our newly remodeled private rooms provide a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere for your vacation getaway. Conveniently situated in downtown Sister Bay, SwedeInn is within walking distance to restaurants, bars, shops, the beach, and other attractions. Leave your car behind and explore all that Sister Bay has to offer during your stay at SwedeInn.

Mill Road Place is a charming institution located at 2330 Mill Road in the picturesque town of Sister Bay, Wisconsin. Offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere, this establishment is dedicated to providing top-quality services and amenities to its patrons. Whether you're looking for a cozy place to stay, a delicious meal to enjoy, or a unique event venue, Mill Road Place has got you covered. Come visit us and experience the charm and hospitality that makes this institution a beloved destination in the heart of Sister Bay.

The Door County Cabin Collective, located at 11098 North Sand Bay Lane in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, offers four unique waterfront cabin rentals in Door County, WI. Escape the hustle and bustle of daily life and enjoy a slower pace at these cozy cabins. Each cabin provides all the amenities you need for a relaxing vacation by the lake, and they are dog friendly too! The Point cabin can accommodate groups of up to 15 and offers stunning views of Clark Lake. The Bay cabin sleeps 8 and features a two-story view of the lake. Porte Haven sits on Lake Michigan and can host up to 12 guests, offering luxury amenities and breathtaking views. Rowleys A-frame is set on Rowleys Bay on Lake Michigan, with a beachfront fire pit and space for up to 10 guests.

Maple Manor, located at 2207 Maple Drive in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, is a unique lodging institution housed in a beautifully renovated historical church. With 8 bedrooms, 6 of which have en-suite bathrooms, Jacuzzi tubs, fireplaces, desks, and sitting areas, Maple Manor offers a luxurious and comfortable stay for guests. The home features a stunning eat-in kitchen with cherry cabinets and granite countertops, a spacious great room with a 25-foot high ceiling, a dining room that seats 10, a large deck, fire pit, grill, and a half-acre county backyard. Formerly the Sister Bay Baptist Church, Maple Manor has a rich history dating back to 1882 when the property was donated by J.J. Wiltse. The church was demolished in 1916 and rebuilt, before a new church was constructed on Hwy 42 in 1975. In 2001, Kurt Reetz purchased and renovated the old church into a second home for his family. In November 2018, Maple Manor was purchased by new owners who have added a finished basement, increasing the capacity to sleep 22 guests.

Timberline Cottage, located on Timberline Road in Ellison Bay, Wisconsin, is a charming vacation home perfect for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Nestled on the tip of Door County, this nostalgic cottage offers a peaceful retreat with easy access to nearby towns such as Sister Bay, Baileys Harbor, and Washington Island. With stunning views, crystal clear water, and nature all around, Timberline Cottage provides a unique and unforgettable experience for guests. The fully screened porch allows guests to enjoy the beauty of the woods without any interruptions from bugs or rain, making it the perfect spot for morning coffee or evening cocktails.

Dovetail Acres is a unique institution located at 2455 Flint Ridge Road in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. As a real estate agency, we specialize in helping clients find their dream homes or investment properties in the picturesque surroundings of Door County. Our experienced agents are dedicated to providing personalized service and expert guidance throughout the buying or selling process. In addition to our real estate services, Dovetail Acres also operates as a travel agency, offering bespoke vacation packages and accommodations in the stunning Midwest region. Whether you're looking for a cozy cabin retreat or a luxurious waterfront estate, we can help you plan the perfect getaway.

Three Kings and Two Queens of Ephraim is a real estate and travel agency located at 2893 Bella Vista Lane in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This modern home in the heart of the charming Village of Sister Bay offers easy access to the marina, beach, shops, and dining options. With four bedrooms and two baths, this vacation retreat can accommodate up to nine guests. The newly finished full daylight basement adds two queen bedrooms, a full bath, a rec room, and ground level patio access. In addition, the home in the Village of Ephraim features three spacious king bedrooms, including a main level master suite, and four bedrooms on the upper level (2 king and 2 queen bedrooms). Come and enjoy a memorable Door County vacation at Three Kings and Two Queens of Ephraim!