Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

"I ordered the pizza special on Tuesday night. Picked it up at the time suggested and couldn't have been more disappointed. This is a treat when we order because we have diabetics in the family and only do this if we allow a cheat day. I also live approximately 3 miles from the Market St. location, so it's close and quick. The pizza had obviously been sitting in the box for some time. It had minimal sauce and tasted like the cardboard pizza box. I picked up the pizza at 4:30 p.m., specifically ordering before the after work rush. I was so disappointed. My 80 year old Mother was as well. She was so looking forward to it. Just another case of well we made it, and that is good enough. No pride in the product."

"It's 2 pm on a Sunday afternoon and I'm giving them another chance here at the Market street location. I realize we are a party of 8 (2 kids) but it's not busy at all, this is why we come at this time. One hour to get our food as I watch tables around us get their meals which came after us. The food was okay, not great. My wife's meatball's were cold and my chicken was only luke warm , no one else really complained but didn't say anything either. Last decent meal I had from them was in Fort Wayne."

"Family Party Place! Super good pizza and wonderful staff! Best yet ...Wonderful family! Papa Dan California"

"Plentiful options for even the pickiest eaters. I appreciate menu variety and BB did not disappoint! Our server was patient with our large group and the food was excellent. I loved the whimsical mismatched stained-glass light shades!"

"(Lunch time 7/20/19) Wow! Simply, Wow! We planned a trip from Indiana to the Ohio Caverns and we always like to try new places to eat, so I Googled pizza places in Lima and Beer Barrel Pizza popped up. The name was intriguing and the pictures of the pizza and reviews told us we had to stop here. Initially we were suspect about the service because several reviews stated it was slow. What we discovered, however, was things ordered from the deep fryer were pretty quick, but if you order a pizza it does take a while. Why? Because it's delicious! What we got was a well crafted, picture perfect pizza that was to die for. Well worth the extra time! They also have an awesome beer selection which paired nicely with our food. The garlic knots were very soft, warm and full of flavor. The garlic butter dipping sauce was outstanding. Jayred was our server and overall did a great job for as busy as they were. He was attentive and engaging and took good care of us. He brought us a box for our pizza and let us take care of it. With the size of the pizza pan and the box, there wasn't room for both on the table. I figured this was a good time to see who would step up and help so I balanced the empty pan on my hand at the edge of the table to see who would help out. There were two girls that walked by and saw it but ignored it. Pretty soon another server walked up and offered to take it so I didn't have to hold it. I didn't catch his name, but i do know he was working the tables across the room and went out of his way to help. So "Thank you" to him. Beer Barrel Pizza is an awesome place and we will be sure to stop again next time we are in the Lima area."