TOP 10 Pizza with homemade ingredients in New York, New York

Welcome to Michelangelo Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Mattituck, New York. Located at 10095 Main Road, our charming pizzeria invites you to savor a delightful array of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. At Michelangelo Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian entrees. Whether you're in the mood for a crispy, wood-fired pizza topped with premium mozzarella and fresh basil or a hearty plate of homemade lasagna, our menu offers something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Original Michelangelo Pizzeria-Restaurant Eastport, the premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Conveniently located at 11 Eastport Manor Road, Eastport, New York 11941, our family-owned establishment has been delighting the local community and beyond with exquisite Italian dishes since 1980. At Original Michelangelo, we pride ourselves on our wide variety of delicious specialty pizzas and Italian creations, each crafted with love and the finest ingredients. Whether you're dining in, picking up your meal, or opting for our convenient delivery service, you'll be impressed by the consistent quality and taste of our home-cooked meals.

Welcome to Crust Around The Corner, East Moriches' beloved pizza haven, where culinary creativity meets classic flavors! Nestled at 345 Montauk Highway E, East Moriches, New York, our restaurant is a cornerstone of delicious dining and community spirit. Known for our innovative pizza creations, we invite you to explore a menu brimming with delightful options, from the classic cheese pizza to our signature "East Moriches style" pizza—a crispy cheese crust topped with our family's special Grandma sauce. Indulge in our unique offerings like the Chicken Cutlet Ranch Pizza with bacon bits or the fiery Spicy BBQ Chicken Pizza. For those seeking a veggie delight, our thin square Grandma pizza, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil, is a must-try. We also cater to gluten-free preferences with our famous homemade 9" personal pies crafted with cauliflower crust.

Welcome to Maggiolino's Italian Restaurant, where authentic Italian flavors and warm hospitality come together to create an unforgettable dining experience. Located at 8195 Seneca Turnpike in the charming town of Clinton, New York, Maggiolino's is your go-to destination for a taste of Italy in the heart of the United States. At Maggiolino's, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that showcases the rich culinary traditions of Italy. Our chefs use only the freshest ingredients to craft classic dishes and innovative creations that will delight your taste buds. From our hand-tossed pizzas and homemade pasta to our savory seafood and succulent meat dishes, every meal is a celebration of flavor and quality.

Welcome to Ruggiero's Trattoria, a charming culinary haven nestled in the heart of Little Falls, New York. Located at 546 East Main Street, our family-owned restaurant offers an authentic taste of Italy right in your neighborhood. At Ruggiero's Trattoria, we pride ourselves on crafting delicious, homemade Italian dishes using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes passed down through generations. Our cozy and inviting atmosphere is perfect for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special celebration with family and friends. Whether you're craving a classic pasta dish, a wood-fired pizza, or a delectable dessert, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every palate. We also offer a fine selection of wines to complement your meal, enhancing your dining experience.

Welcome to Nicoletta's Italian Cafe, a cherished culinary gem nestled in the heart of Cooperstown, New York. Located at 96 Main Street, our inviting restaurant offers an authentic Italian dining experience that transports you straight to the vibrant streets of Italy. At Nicoletta's, we pride ourselves on serving a delightful array of traditional Italian dishes, crafted with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor. Whether you're savoring our homemade pasta, indulging in our signature pizzas, or enjoying a glass of fine wine from our carefully curated selection, each visit promises a memorable experience. Our warm and welcoming atmosphere, combined with attentive service, makes Nicoletta's Italian Cafe the perfect destination for a romantic dinner, family gathering, or casual meal with friends.

Welcome to Wise Guys Sammy's, a culinary gem located at 261-267 Main Street in the heart of Oneonta, New York. Known for its mouthwatering creations, Wise Guys Sammy's is more than just a restaurant; it's a destination for food lovers seeking the finest flavors in the area. At Wise Guys Sammy's, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that features everything from delectable pizzas to hearty sandwiches, all crafted with the freshest ingredients. Our specialty pizzas, like the garlic and oil base topped with ricotta and mozzarella, or the house-made marinara with mushrooms, spinach, and roasted red peppers, are a must-try for any pizza enthusiast.

Welcome to Nick's Diner and Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious dining in Oneonta, New York! Located at 220 Chestnut Street, our cozy eatery combines the comfort of a classic diner with the savory delights of a pizzeria, offering a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. At Nick's, we pride ourselves on serving a wide array of mouthwatering dishes, from hearty breakfasts to delectable pizzas and everything in between. Start your day with our fluffy buttermilk pancakes, savory omelets, or indulgent stuffed French toast, all made with the freshest ingredients. For lunch and dinner, enjoy our signature pizzas, including favorites like the white garlic pizza topped with chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, and BBQ sauce or the seafood delight with white clam sauce, mozzarella, shrimp, crab, scallops, and a drizzle of Franks hot sauce.