TOP 10 Make restaurant reservations in Geneseo, New York

Pizza Paul's is a beloved institution located at 110 Main Street in Geneseo, New York. Since 1993, this pizzeria has been a staple in the Lakeville and Geneseo communities, founded by the dynamic duo, Paul and Catherine Miller. Paul Miller, a pizza maestro with decades of experience, has passed down his dedication to perfecting the art of pizza-making to his daughter Teresa and her husband Craig. At Pizza Paul's, we serve more than just pizza; we serve tradition, community, and a slice of home. Our commitment to quality and authenticity is evident in every mouthwatering slice we serve. Whether you're enjoying a classic or one of our innovative creations like the Subzone, we aim to surprise and delight your taste buds with every visit.