The 30 Best Italian food recommendations in New York City, New York

Carmela's Ristorante is a charming Italian restaurant located at 912 Hempstead Turnpike in Franklin Square, New York. Known for its delicious and authentic Italian cuisine, Carmela's offers a wide range of dishes including pasta, pizza, seafood, and more. Whether you dine in at their cozy restaurant or opt for their convenient meal delivery service, you're sure to enjoy a truly satisfying dining experience. Come taste the flavors of Italy at Carmela's Ristorante today!

Grandpa Tony's is a cozy and inviting bar and restaurant located at 101 Althouse Avenue in East Rockaway, New York. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, this establishment is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious food and drinks with friends and family. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a night out on the town, Grandpa Tony's has something for everyone. Come and experience the friendly service and mouthwatering dishes that make this hidden gem a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Mi Olivia Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 660 Fulton Avenue in Hempstead, New York. This cozy restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with a menu full of delicious and authentic dishes. From savory appetizers to mouth-watering entrees, Mi Olivia Restaurant serves up a taste of traditional flavors that will leave your taste buds wanting more. Whether you're looking for a casual meal with friends or a special dinner date, this restaurant is the perfect spot to enjoy a satisfying and memorable meal. Come and experience the warm hospitality and delectable cuisine at Mi Olivia Restaurant today!

Via Roma Pizza is a popular restaurant located at 1764 Merrick Avenue in Merrick, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, pastas, and Italian dishes, Via Roma Pizza offers a wide variety of options for dine-in, takeout, or delivery. Whether you are craving a classic Margherita pizza or a hearty bowl of pasta, Via Roma Pizza has something for everyone. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this institution is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Experience the taste of Italy right here in the heart of Merrick at Via Roma Pizza.

Don Mario is a charming and cozy restaurant located at 7204 3rd Avenue in New York, United States. Specializing in delicious and authentic Latin American cuisine, Don Mario offers a wide variety of mouthwatering dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. Whether you're in the mood for traditional empanadas, succulent grilled meats, or flavorful seafood dishes, Don Mario has something for everyone. The warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with exceptional service, makes dining at Don Mario a truly memorable experience. Come and indulge in the flavors of Latin America at Don Mario today!

Domenico's is a lively bar and restaurant located on Hempstead Turnpike in Levittown, New York. Known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere, Domenico's offers a diverse menu of Italian and American cuisine, as well as a wide selection of drinks. Whether you're looking to enjoy a casual meal with friends or catch a game on TV, Domenico's is the perfect spot to relax and unwind. With its friendly staff and cozy ambiance, this institution is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

La Strada is a cozy and inviting bar, food, and restaurant located at 2100 Merrick Avenue in Merrick, New York. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, La Strada offers a delicious menu of Italian cuisine, as well as a variety of specialty cocktails and wines. Whether you're looking for a casual meal with friends or a romantic dinner for two, La Strada is the perfect spot to enjoy great food and drinks in a charming setting. Come visit us and experience the flavors of Italy right here in Merrick.

Located at 345 Court Street in New York, Marco Polo is a renowned bar, food, and restaurant institution in the heart of Carroll Gardens. Serving both northern and southern Italian cuisine, Marco Polo has been a beloved dining destination since 1983. Chef specials are a daily highlight, showcasing the best of Venetian and Southern Italian flavors. With over 40 years in business, proud owner Joseph Chirico invites guests to enjoy a delightful dining experience at Marco Polo. The recently revamped menu features traditional dishes like black seafood risotto and innovative creations such as barbabietola salad. Whether you're a long-time patron or a new diner, Marco Polo's new interior design and menu are sure to impress with dishes like pappardelle with Tuscan veal ragu and braised lamb shank. Come and experience the legacy of Marco Polo in Brooklyn.

Georgina is a charming restaurant located at 1003 East 163rd Street in New York, United States. Known for its delicious and diverse menu offerings, Georgina is a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff make dining at Georgina a truly enjoyable experience. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Georgina has something for everyone. Come visit us and taste the flavors of our carefully crafted dishes at Georgina.

Albas Pizza and Restaurant is a cozy and inviting eatery located at 36-20 Ditmars Boulevard in New York. Known for its delicious pizzas and a variety of other Italian dishes, this restaurant is a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make dining here a pleasurable experience. Whether you're looking for a quick slice of pizza or a full sit-down meal, Albas Pizza and Restaurant has something for everyone. Come and enjoy a taste of Italy in the heart of New York City.

Raimo's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Trattoria of Amityville is a charming restaurant located at 45 Merrick Road in Amityville, New York. We specialize in serving hot, oven-fresh pizza with all your favorite toppings, as well as a variety of delicious Italian dishes. We recommend making a reservation ahead of time to ensure you have a table for your special occasion. Whether it's a birthday party, office function, or just a casual meal with friends, we take care of all the fine details to bring your event to life.

Il Poeta is a charming bar and restaurant located at 98-04 Metropolitan Avenue in New York, United States. Chef Mario Di Chiara, renowned for his culinary expertise, is the mastermind behind the delectable dishes served at Il Poeta. With a menu inspired by traditional Italian cuisine, guests can enjoy a wide range of mouth-watering dishes prepared with the freshest ingredients. Whether you're looking to enjoy a casual meal or celebrate a special occasion, Il Poeta offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for any dining experience. Don't miss the opportunity to taste Chef Mario Di Chiara's creations and experience true Italian hospitality at Il Poeta.

Magna Restaurant is a charming dining establishment located at 35-25 Farrington Street in New York, United States. This restaurant offers a diverse menu of delicious dishes, featuring a fusion of international flavors and local ingredients. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service make it a perfect spot for a casual meal or special occasion. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely dining experience, Magna Restaurant is sure to satisfy your culinary cravings. Come and enjoy a delightful meal at this hidden gem in the heart of New York City.

Bella's Place is a cozy restaurant located at 8777 Sutphin Boulevard in New York, United States. We specialize in homemade comfort food and offer convenient meal delivery services for those looking to enjoy our delicious dishes in the comfort of their own home. Our menu features a variety of options to satisfy all taste buds, from hearty soups and sandwiches to flavorful entrees and decadent desserts. Come dine with us at Bella's Place for a truly satisfying and comforting meal experience.

Valdari NYC is a charming restaurant located at 214-26 41st Avenue in New York City, offering a delightful dining experience for food enthusiasts. With a focus on high-quality ingredients and creative culinary techniques, Valdari NYC serves up a diverse menu of delectable dishes that are sure to satisfy every palate. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner, a casual lunch with friends, or a special celebration with family, Valdari NYC provides a warm and inviting atmosphere for all occasions. Come and experience the delicious flavors and exceptional service that make Valdari NYC a must-visit destination in the bustling city of New York.

Mulberry Street Babylon is a family-owned upscale pizzeria located at 30 East Main Street in Babylon, New York. Known for its high-quality food made from the freshest ingredients, this restaurant offers a variety of delicious dishes such as Caprese salad, pepperoni and cheese flatbread pizza, penne alla vodka, and chicken parm. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere make it a great spot for a special night out or a casual meal. Customers can order directly from the restaurant or through DoorDash or Uber Eats. Reservations are recommended to secure a table at this hidden gem in Babylon Village. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a full dining experience, Mulberry Street Babylon is a must-visit destination for anyone in the area.

EBEN-EZER is a cozy and welcoming restaurant located at 126 Jefferson Street in Inwood, New York. Our establishment offers a wide variety of delicious and freshly prepared food options for our customers to enjoy. Whether you are looking for a quick bite to eat or a sit-down meal with friends and family, EBEN-EZER has something for everyone. Our friendly staff is dedicated to providing excellent service to ensure that your dining experience is enjoyable and memorable. Come visit us at EBEN-EZER and indulge in a culinary delight that will leave you coming back for more.

Trattoria DiMeo is a charming Italian restaurant located at 183 Roslyn Road in Roslyn Heights, New York. This cozy trattoria offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy delicious Italian cuisine and a wide selection of wines and cocktails. With a menu featuring traditional Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, Trattoria DiMeo is the perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends or a romantic date night. Whether you're craving pasta, pizza, or seafood, this restaurant has something to satisfy every palate. Come experience the authentic flavors of Italy at Trattoria DiMeo.

Emilia is a charming restaurant located at 195 Brower Avenue in Rockville Centre, New York. This cozy establishment offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying delicious meals with friends and family. Emilia specializes in serving up delectable food made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for classic Italian dishes, savory seafood options, or mouthwatering desserts, Emilia has something to satisfy every craving. Come dine at Emilia and experience a culinary journey that will leave you coming back for more.

Rialto is a cozy bar and restaurant located at 588 Westbury Avenue in Carle Place, New York. Known for its great food and warm service, Rialto is the perfect place to enjoy a unique culinary experience. Executive Chef Katia Ramirez brings her creative Mediterranean cuisine to Long Island, creating lasting memories with every dish. The restaurant is closed on Mondays, but open from 3 pm to 10 pm on Tuesdays through Thursdays, 3 pm to 11 pm on Fridays and Saturdays, and 3 pm to 9 pm on Sundays. Guests rave about the "top-notch" Italian cuisine, including delicious whole fish dishes, served with style by the friendly hosts. While the prices may be on the higher side, customers agree that the experience is worth every penny.

La Paz Deli & Restaurant is a cozy eatery located at 377 B Nassau Road in Roosevelt, New York. Serving up a delicious blend of traditional Latin American and American cuisine, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. From hearty sandwiches and salads to flavorful entrees and desserts, La Paz Deli & Restaurant offers a diverse menu to satisfy all taste buds. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and affordable prices, this establishment is the perfect spot for a casual meal or special occasion. Come experience the flavors of La Paz Deli & Restaurant today!

Las Gemelas Deli & Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 44 North Main Street in Freeport, New York. This family-owned establishment offers a variety of delicious dishes that are sure to satisfy every palate. From freshly made sandwiches and salads to hearty entrees, Las Gemelas Deli & Restaurant has something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal, this cozy restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy a delicious meal in a welcoming atmosphere. Visit Las Gemelas Deli & Restaurant today and experience the delectable flavors that have made it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Sal's Place is a cozy and inviting bar and restaurant located at 1495 Hicksville Road in North Massapequa, New York. Known for its delicious food and friendly atmosphere, Sal's Place is the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat or enjoy a drink with friends. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a night out on the town, Sal's Place has something for everyone. Come visit us and see why we're a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Located at 485 West Montauk Highway in Lindenhurst, New York, Goccia D'Oro II is a vibrant bar, food, and restaurant institution that offers a unique dining experience. With a diverse menu featuring Italian cuisine and a wide selection of drinks, patrons can enjoy delicious meals in a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking to unwind after a long day or celebrate a special occasion, Goccia D'Oro II is the perfect destination for a memorable dining experience.

Alletto's Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 218 East Montauk Highway in Lindenhurst, New York. Known for its delicious Italian cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere, this restaurant offers a wide range of dishes to satisfy any craving. From homemade pasta to mouthwatering seafood dishes, Alletto's is sure to please even the most discerning palate. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner for two or a family-friendly meal, Alletto's Restaurant is the perfect choice for a memorable dining experience in the heart of Long Island.

Santino’s Gourmet Deli And Restaurant is a cozy and inviting establishment located at 409 Forest Avenue in New York, United States. This unique institution offers a wide range of delicious gourmet food options, including sandwiches, salads, and homemade dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. With a warm and friendly atmosphere, Santino’s is the perfect spot to grab a quick bite to eat or enjoy a leisurely meal with friends and family. Whether you're looking for a tasty sandwich on the go or a sit-down dining experience, Santino’s Gourmet Deli And Restaurant has something for everyone.

Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage is a unique food establishment located at 1157 Culver Road in Rochester, New York, United States. Specializing in meal takeaway and restaurant services, we pride ourselves on sourcing seasonal produce and meat proteins from local sustainable farmers, importing high-quality ingredients from Italy, and making our own cheeses and sausages in-house. Our goal is to provide our customers with pizzas that are made with the freshest and most flavorful ingredients possible. We highly recommend pre-ordering your meal, as orders can be placed up to 1 week in advance. Visit us today for a delicious and satisfying dining experience!

Johnny C's Pizza & Restaurant is a popular dining spot located in Schenectady, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and mouth-watering Italian dishes, this cozy restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for guests to enjoy a satisfying meal. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty plate of pasta, Johnny C's has something for everyone. With friendly service and top-notch ingredients, this is the perfect place to indulge in your favorite comfort foods. Come visit us at 1821 Altamont Avenue and experience the flavors of Johnny C's Pizza & Restaurant for yourself!

High Bridge Pizza, located at 1262 Highbridge Road in Schenectady, New York, is a popular pizzeria known for its fresh offerings and classic pizzas. The menu is customizable for catering events, with options to fit any taste and budget. Online ordering is available for convenience, with quick pick-up or delivery options. Customers rave about the outstanding food and service at High Bridge Pizza, with many praising the owner and staff for their friendliness. The square pizza with ground sausage, peppers, and cheese is a favorite among patrons. The chef salad is also a popular choice, with a variety of fresh ingredients.

Empire Pizza is a popular food institution located at 2551 Albany Street in Schenectady, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and a variety of other mouth-watering dishes, Empire Pizza offers meal delivery and takeaway services for those looking to enjoy a tasty meal in the comfort of their own home. With a cozy and inviting restaurant atmosphere, Empire Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike who crave a satisfying and satisfying meal.