Top 30 Best Cozy dinner restaurants in Oyster Bay, New York

Welcome to Southold Bay Oysters, your premier destination for fresh and delectable seafood in Southold, New York. Nestled at 10273 North Bayview Road, our charming restaurant offers a quintessential taste of the North Fork's maritime heritage.

Foster Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 39 Roslyn Avenue in Sea Cliff, New York. Offering a cozy and inviting atmosphere, this restaurant specializes in delicious food that is sure to satisfy any craving.

Schultzy's Restaurant is a dream come true for the owner, who has always wanted to bring a true 'bay-to-table' concept to the community of Bayville, New York.

La Cantina Bay is a charming restaurant located at 98 Jackson Avenue in Syosset, New York. This cozy eatery offers a diverse menu of delicious dishes inspired by traditional Mexican cuisine.

Samovar Restaurant, located at 27 Woodbury Road in Hicksville, New York, is a charming dining establishment that specializes in traditional Russian cuisine.

The Shed Restaurant in Plainview, New York is a cozy and inviting establishment located at 1511 Old Country Road. As a bar and restaurant, it offers a diverse menu of delicious food and drinks for guests to enjoy.

Located at 1053 Oyster Bay Road in East Norwich, New York, Hunter Restaurant is a charming bistro known for its innovative take on classic French and Spanish cuisine.

Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay) is a beloved restaurant located at 342 Lexington Avenue in Oyster Bay, New York.

Piccolo Cantina Bay is a charming Italian restaurant located at 2 Bayville Avenue in the picturesque town of Locust Valley, New York.

Me & You Restaurant is a cozy and inviting eatery located at 326 Broadway in Bethpage, New York. Our restaurant offers a diverse menu of delicious dishes that cater to all tastes and preferences.

Osaka Sushi Japanese Restaurant is a popular dining destination located at 188 West Old Country Road in Hicksville, New York.

Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay is a beloved Italian restaurant located at 253 Pine Hollow Road in Oyster Bay, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, pastas, and other Italian specialties, Mario's offers both dine-in and meal delivery services.

Umberto's of Oyster Bay is a charming restaurant located at 25 East Main Street in Oyster Bay, New York. This beloved establishment offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a delicious meal with family and friends.

Two25 Restaurant is a charming dining establishment located at 225 Birch Hill Road in the picturesque town of Locust Valley, New York.

Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy eatery located at 19 Hicksville Road in Massapequa, New York. Our establishment offers a wide variety of delicious Italian cuisine, including freshly baked pizzas, pasta dishes, salads, and more.

Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy dining establishment located at 188 Merritts Road in Farmingdale, New York.

American Beauty Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 1026 Park Boulevard in Massapequa Park, New York. This cozy restaurant offers a delectable menu filled with classic American dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving.

Tiny Thai Restaurant is a cozy and authentic eatery located at 187 Main Street in Farmingdale, New York. This charming establishment offers a taste of Thailand right in the heart of the United States.

Zona Italian Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 4883 Merrick Road in Massapequa Park, New York. Specializing in authentic Italian cuisine, Zona offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion.

Pappardelle's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy and inviting dining establishment located at 554 Stewart Avenue in Bethpage, New York.

Barney's Restaurant is a cozy and inviting eatery located at 315 Buckram Road in Locust Valley, New York.

Francesco's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a popular dining establishment located at 131 Central Park Road in Plainview, New York.

El Parral Restaurant is a vibrant and inviting establishment located at 8 Berry Hill Road in Syosset, New York. This popular bar and restaurant offers a diverse menu of delicious food and drinks, perfect for any occasion.

Pulcinella Neapolitan Restaurant is a charming Italian eatery located at 746 North Broadway in North Massapequa, New York.

Dominican Restaurant 4 is a vibrant and authentic dining destination located at 305 Main Street in Farmingdale, New York.

La Union Oyster & Clam Bar is a charming seafood restaurant located at 102 North Franklin Street in Hempstead, New York. Known for serving up fresh and delicious oysters and clams, this institution is a must-visit for seafood lovers in the area.

Luigi Q Italian Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 400 South Oyster Bay Road in Hicksville, New York.

Roseti's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a beloved dining destination located at 910 Carmans Road in Massapequa, New York. This cozy eatery offers a wide variety of delicious Italian dishes, including mouthwatering pizzas, savory pastas, and flavorful entrees.

Shaheen Restaurant is a popular dining destination located at 253 South Broadway in Hicksville, New York. This restaurant offers a diverse menu of delicious dishes, including traditional Indian and Pakistani cuisine.

Kam Garden Restaurant is a cozy and welcoming eatery located at 12 Berry Hill Road in Syosset, New York. Known for its delicious Chinese cuisine, this restaurant offers a wide variety of dishes to satisfy any craving.