TOP 30 Best Classic pizza toppings in Buffalo, New York

Extra Extra Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located at 549 West Utica Street in Buffalo, New York. Known for their delicious and freshly made pizzas, Extra Extra Pizza offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to choose from. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, this institution is perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a unique vegetarian option, Extra Extra Pizza has something for everyone. Come and enjoy a slice of mouthwatering pizza at this must-visit food spot in Buffalo.

ANDIAMO PIZZA is a popular restaurant located at 115 East 23rd Street in New York City, specializing in delicious thin-crust pizzas with a variety of toppings. From classic Margherita to unique combinations like BBQ chicken and buffalo chicken, there's something for every pizza lover. In addition to their signature pizzas, they also offer a range of calzones, salads, pasta dishes, and appetizers like mozzarella sticks and calamari. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, ANDIAMO PIZZA is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. So come on in and enjoy a slice of New York's finest pizza at ANDIAMO PIZZA!

Located at 600 West 57th Street in New York, Pizza Shack is a popular food institution offering a wide variety of delicious pizza options. From classic cheese pies to unique creations like BBQ Chicken and Buffalo Chicken, there is something for everyone at Pizza Shack. In addition to pizza, they also offer sandwiches, salads, calzones, and garlic knots. With convenient delivery and takeout options, Pizza Shack makes it easy to enjoy their tasty offerings. So next time you're craving a slice of New York's best pizza, be sure to stop by Pizza Shack and discover your new favorite flavor. Pay by credit card for a hassle-free experience.

Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza is a popular food institution located at 444 Borden Road in West Seneca, New York. Specializing in delicious pizzas and other mouth-watering dishes, this restaurant offers a variety of options such as chicken, tomatoes, onions, peppers, fresh basil & olive oil, beer battered fresh fish, buffalo chicken, steak, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, and grilled chicken wraps with fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers. Supporting local businesses, Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza is a favorite among West Seneca residents and has become one of the most popular pizzerias in the area. With a partnership with Slice since 2024, this restaurant has been a staple in the community for years. Enjoy the best pizza in West Seneca like the locals do and discover some of the top dishes in the area.

Located at 217 East 86th Street in New York, Mimi's Pizza is a popular food institution offering a variety of delicious pizza options. From classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms to unique combinations like buffalo chicken and truffle oil, there is something for every pizza lover at Mimi's. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also serves up tasty appetizers like deep-fried cheese sticks and garlic knots, as well as fresh salads and pasta dishes. Whether you're looking for a quick slice on the go or a full meal with friends and family, Mimi's Pizza has you covered with their tasty and satisfying menu options.

Located in New York, Ray's Pizza Bar is a popular food institution offering a variety of delicious dishes. From classic pizzas to pasta, salads, and more, there is something for everyone at this restaurant. Their holiday special includes a half tray of pasta, pizza, salad, and soda, perfect for sharing with friends and family. With options like spaghetti marinara, fettuccine alfredo, and chicken buffalo pizza, the menu is sure to satisfy any craving. Don't miss out on their garlic knots, cheese sticks, and crispy chicken wings for the perfect appetizers. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Ray's Pizza Bar is a must-visit for anyone looking for top-quality food in New York. With convenient curbside pickup and regular special offers, this local business is a favorite among the community. Don't forget to try their famous French fries and Italian donut holes for a truly satisfying meal. Visit Ray's Pizza Bar today and experience the best that New York has to offer.

John's Pizza, located at 69 Devoe Avenue in Yonkers, New York, is a beloved institution known for its classic square, thick crust pizzas. With toppings like mushrooms, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and olives, as well as options for buffalo chicken and lasagna, John's Pizza offers a variety of delicious choices. Their menu also includes savory stuffed breads, pasta dishes like baked ziti and ricotta stuffed shells, and chicken and eggplant entrees. Yonkers residents have made John's Pizza a popular spot in the area, and with good reason. The restaurant has been a staple of the community for years, offering tasty food and regular deals to keep customers coming back for more. Whether you're looking for a quick meal to go or a cozy sit-down dinner, John's Pizza has something for everyone. Stay connected with the latest updates and specials on social media, and don't forget to try some of the top dishes in Yonkers during your visit.

Located at 62-69 Dry Harbor Road in New York, Gino's of Middle Village Pizza is a renowned food institution offering a variety of delicious dishes. From crispy deep-fried cheese sticks to classic garlic knots, thick crust square pizza to thin Sicilian crust options, there is something for every pizza lover. The menu also includes classic cheese or build-your-own pizza options, along with tasty French fries, buffalo chicken wings, steamed broccoli, and more. For those looking for something other than pizza, there are also grilled chicken paninis, pasta dishes, and stuffed shells available. Gino's of Middle Village Pizza has been a local favorite for years, offering top-quality food with convenient curbside pickup options. Visit this popular restaurant to experience the best pizzas in Middle Village and beyond. Pay by credit card for a hassle-free dining experience.

Ricky’s Pizza is a popular food institution located at 119-11 Jamaica Avenue in New York, United States. Specializing in classic cheese and create-your-own pizzas, Ricky’s also offers a variety of delicious toppings such as fresh mozzarella, garlic, BBQ chicken, buffalo chicken, eggplant, and more. In addition to pizzas, Ricky’s menu includes a selection of salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, and side dishes. Customers can enjoy their meals with options like garlic bread, caesar salad, stuffed shells, lobster ravioli, and veal cutlet. The restaurant is known for its high-quality ingredients and generous portions, ensuring that customers leave satisfied. As a Slice partner for one year, Ricky's Pizza has become a beloved establishment in the community, known for its delicious food and excellent service. Customers can easily order and pick up their meals with curbside pickup, and payment can be made by credit card for convenience. Experience the best pizza in Queens at Ricky’s Pizza and explore their diverse menu to find your new favorites.

Welcome to Rocco's Pizza, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Patchogue, New York. Located at 253 Medford Avenue, our family-owned restaurant offers an extensive menu that promises to tantalize your taste buds and satisfy your cravings. Known for serving some of the best pizza in Patchogue, Rocco's Pizza combines fresh ingredients and traditional recipes to deliver a truly unforgettable dining experience. Our diverse menu features a variety of mouth-watering options. From classic toppings like sausage, pepperoni, and extra cheese to gourmet creations featuring buffalo chicken, ricotta, and fresh basil, there's a pizza for every palate. But our offerings don't stop at pizza. Indulge in our succulent chicken cutlets, savory meatballs, and a selection of pasta dishes that range from creamy Alfredo to tangy marinara sauces. For those looking for lighter fare, we offer fresh salads and delicious sandwiches filled with premium meats and cheeses.

Maria's Pizza is a renowned food institution located at 2041 Saw Mill River Road in Yorktown Heights, New York, United States. Specializing in delicious Italian cuisine, Maria's Pizza offers a wide range of mouth-watering dishes such as Tortellini loaded with sausage and cherry peppers, Fried Calamari with house-made Marinara Sauce, and limited-time Pumpkin Style fried dough. Other delectable options include Cheese Tortellini in a Creamy Parmesan Alfredo Sauce, Buffalo chicken dip, and Butterflied Breaded Shrimp with Marinara Sauce and Melted Mozzarella. Maria's Famous 3 Foot Pizza has been a favorite since 1980, and their menu also features a variety of pasta dishes, sandwiches, appetizers, and salads. Whether you're craving classic Italian flavors or looking to try something new, Maria's Pizza is the perfect destination for a satisfying meal. Don't miss out on their signature honey-infused chili peppers and mini Italian donut holes for a unique and delightful dining experience. Visit Maria's Pizza today at 2041 Saw Mill River Road for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere.

Tuscan Pizza Crust is a renowned food institution located at 2021 Bailey Avenue in Buffalo, New York. Specializing in delicious and savory pizzas, this restaurant offers a wide variety of toppings and flavors to satisfy any pizza lover's cravings. From classic margherita to unique combinations like eggplant with marinara sauce and fresh basil, there is something for everyone at Tuscan Pizza Crust. In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, Tuscan Pizza Crust also offers a range of salads, appetizers, sandwiches, and pasta dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a crispy chicken Caesar salad or a hearty plate of baked ziti with marinara sauce, the menu has something to please every palate.

Classic Crust Brick and Mortar is a popular food institution located at 989 Main Street in New York, United States. Specializing in delicious brick oven pizzas, their menu features a variety of mouth-watering options such as Classic Cheese, Pepperoni, Margherita, Pulled Pork, Brie Pear, Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lover's, Chicken Jalapeno, Fig Goat Cheese, BLT, Truffle Mushroom, Sausage Peppers, Veggie, Wickle Pickle, and Lobster Pizza. The institution also offers a unique mobile catering experience through their Classic Crust Pizza truck, serving the Capital District and beyond. With a cozy brick and mortar location and a diverse menu of delectable pizzas, Classic Crust is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

Welcome to Paisanos Pizza & Catering, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Lake Ronkonkoma, New York. Located at 708 Portion Road, our restaurant is a cherished local gem known for its delectable pizzas, mouth-watering meals, and exceptional catering services. Dive into a world of flavors with our diverse menu, featuring everything from classic New York-style pizzas with fresh mozzarella and imported Italian seasonings to innovative dishes like our spiralized pepperoni pizza and BBQ chicken delights. Our menu is a testament to our commitment to quality and authenticity. Indulge in our crispy zucchini sticks, savory fried calamari, or our golden-brown cheese ravioli. For a lighter fare, explore our selection of fresh salads, each crafted with a unique blend of ingredients and dressings. Our pasta dishes are a must-try, with options like cheese tortellini in a pink cream sauce or our signature lasagna topped with classic cheese and tomato sauce.

Welcome to Primavera Pizza, your go-to destination for mouthwatering Italian cuisine in Mattituck, New York. Nestled at 13500 Main Road, we offer a delightful array of food options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. As a beloved local pizzeria, we've been serving the community with passion and dedication, becoming a favorite spot for residents and visitors alike. At Primavera Pizza, we take pride in crafting delicious meals using only the freshest ingredients. Our menu features a variety of delectable options, from our classic cheese pizzas with thin crust to specialty creations like ricotta and baby spinach pizza, and BBQ chicken with mozzarella. Indulge in our savory sandwiches, fresh salads, and hearty calzones. Don't miss our signature garlic knots, a perfect accompaniment to any meal.

Located at 434 East 72nd Street in New York City, York Ave Pizza is a popular cafe and restaurant known for its delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or want to create your own with a variety of toppings, York Ave Pizza has you covered. They offer personal, small, and large sizes, as well as unique options like a 10'' rice flour pizza and cauliflower crust. In addition to pizza, they also serve a variety of pasta dishes, sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. With options like buffalo chicken pizza, vodka sauce pasta, and eggplant parmesan, there's something for everyone at York Ave Pizza. They also offer meal delivery services for those who prefer to enjoy their food at home. Visit York Ave Pizza today and experience the delicious flavors of New York City.

Pizza Sangiorgi is a cozy pizzeria located at 4502 New York 364 in Canandaigua, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, this restaurant offers a variety of toppings and styles to satisfy any craving. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or looking to try something new like buffalo chicken or BBQ pulled pork, Pizza Sangiorgi has something for everyone. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, this restaurant is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty meal with family and friends.

Located at 3617 East Tremont Avenue in New York, Cestra's Pizza is a top destination for delicious Italian cuisine. From classic cheese pizzas to specialty combinations like White, Buffalo Chicken, Penne Vodka, and Margherita, there is something for everyone. In addition to pizza, the menu offers appetizers like garlic knots and mozzarella sticks, salads, heros, pasta dishes, and seafood options. Cestra's Pizza also provides catering services for events and occasions. Be sure to keep an eye out for deals and coupons on the menu. Whether dining in, ordering for pickup, or opting for delivery through Slice, Cestra's Pizza promises outstanding food and service.

Welcome to Alvarez Pizza - A Taste of Tradition in Patchogue! Nestled in the heart of Patchogue at 8 West 1st Street, Alvarez Pizza is your go-to destination for authentic, mouth-watering pizzas and a delightful array of Italian dishes. As a beloved local staple, we pride ourselves on serving the freshest ingredients and classic recipes that have made us a favorite among residents and visitors alike.

Welcome to North End Pizza & Tap, where culinary excellence meets a cozy, inviting atmosphere! Located at 50 Auert Avenue, Utica, New York, our establishment is the perfect destination for food lovers and those seeking a delightful dining experience. As a premier bar and restaurant, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive menu featuring hand-crafted dishes made with the freshest ingredients. Indulge in our signature hand-breaded fresh haddock sandwich, served on a toasted roll with homemade tartar sauce, crisp iceberg lettuce, and juicy tomato, accompanied by a side of golden fries. Our menu also boasts mouth-watering starters like hand-breaded mozzarella, deep-fried to perfection with a side of marinara, and our fresh-baked long hot peppers, overstuffed with a savory mix of locally sourced sausage, ground beef, and cheeses, drizzled with sweet balsamic glaze.

Labella Pizza of Wynantskill is a beloved food institution located at 174 Main Avenue in Wynantskill, New York. As a popular restaurant specializing in delicious pizza, Labella Pizza offers a wide variety of mouthwatering options for both dine-in and delivery. From classic cheese and pepperoni to gourmet toppings like buffalo chicken and BBQ pulled pork, there is something for every pizza lover at Labella. With a commitment to using only the freshest ingredients and providing exceptional customer service, Labella Pizza of Wynantskill is a go-to spot for satisfying meals in the area.

Pizza Boy II is a food institution located at 58-19 Woodside Avenue in New York, United States. Specializing in meal takeaways and restaurant dining, Pizza Boy II offers a variety of delicious dishes for customers to enjoy. From sauceless pies topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese to BBQ chicken pizza and buffalo wings, there is something for everyone at Pizza Boy II. The menu also includes classic Italian dishes such as stuffed shells, veal marsala, and shrimp scampi. For dessert, customers can indulge in classic cheesecake, tiramisu, and cannolis. With a focus on using the freshest ingredients, Pizza Boy II is dedicated to providing customers with high-quality and authentic food. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or a specialty pie, Pizza Boy II has something for every craving.

Grand Avenue Pizza, located at 34-24 30th Avenue in New York, United States, has been a beloved institution in the neighborhood of Astoria since 1965. Specializing in food delivery, takeout, and dine-in options, Grand Avenue Pizza takes pride in providing exceptional service and delicious food. Customers rave about the wide variety of toppings available for their pizzas, as well as the delicious sandwiches and calamari on the menu. The buffalo chicken pizza and spinach artichoke slices are highly recommended by patrons. The staff at Grand Avenue Pizza are known for their friendliness and helpfulness, making every visit a pleasant experience. With a reputation for serving the best classic NY slice in the area, Grand Avenue Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Astoria.

Ricotta's Pizza Niagara, located at 349 Niagara Street in Buffalo, New York, is a popular food institution offering delicious meal delivery and dine-in options. Their menu features a variety of classic pizzas with toppings such as olive oil, oregano, garlic, and a blend of cheeses. They also offer tasty options like taco pizza, chicken finger pizza, and Greek salad. In addition to their pizza offerings, Ricotta's Pizza Niagara serves up mouthwatering sandwiches like cheesesteaks and chicken subs. The restaurant has been a staple in the Buffalo community for years, known for their fresh ingredients and top-notch customer service.

Pizza Village is a cozy and welcoming restaurant located at 71 Lake Shore Drive West in Dunkirk, New York. Specializing in delicious and freshly made pizzas, this institution offers a wide variety of toppings to choose from. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or something more adventurous like buffalo chicken, Pizza Village has something for everyone. With convenient meal delivery services available, you can enjoy their mouthwatering pizzas in the comfort of your own home. Come visit Pizza Village for a tasty and satisfying dining experience.

Wise Guys Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located at 1965 Seneca Street in Buffalo, New York. Known for their delicious and authentic New York-style pizza, Wise Guys Pizza offers a variety of toppings and specialty pizzas to choose from. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or a gourmet specialty pie, Wise Guys Pizza has something for everyone. Come in and taste why Wise Guys Pizza is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Located at 3500 Main Street in Buffalo, New York, Gino's NY Pizza at University Plaza offers a wide variety of delicious food options. From BBQ chicken pizza to classic pepperoni, there is something for everyone at this popular restaurant. In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, Gino's NY Pizza also serves up salads, calzones, sandwiches, and more. With options like garlic bread with fresh spinach and melted mozzarella, or boneless chicken breast with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, there is no shortage of tasty dishes to choose from. Don't forget to save room for dessert, as Gino's NY Pizza offers classic cheesecake with a rich and creamy consistency. Whether you dine in or opt for curbside pickup, be sure to try the local favorite, Barbecue Chicken Pizza, and see why residents of Buffalo rave about Gino's NY Pizza. With a partnership with Slice for 6 years, this restaurant has become a staple in the community. Follow them on social media for the latest news and deals, and experience the delicious offerings for yourself.

DeLinda's Pizza, located at 3725 Dewey Avenue in Rochester, New York, is a top choice for delicious, high-quality pizzas and chicken wings. Our pizzas are made with the finest ingredients and crafted with care, ensuring every bite is full of flavor. From classic pepperoni to unique specialty options, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Our chicken wings are a customer favorite, cooked to perfection with our homemade wing sauces and fresh chicken. Choose from Buffalo mild, medium, hot, or sweet and sour flavors, and don't forget to specify if you prefer your wings extra crispy. DeLinda's Pizza is the perfect spot for a satisfying meal, whether you dine in or opt for delivery.

Dollar Slice Pizza is a popular eatery located at 1723 Broadway in the heart of New York City. Known for its delicious and affordable pizza slices, this restaurant offers a wide variety of toppings to choose from. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni slice or something more adventurous like buffalo chicken, Dollar Slice Pizza has something for everyone. With its convenient location and budget-friendly prices, it's the perfect spot to grab a quick and satisfying meal in the bustling city.

Salerno Pizza, located at 29-24 30th Avenue in New York, is a popular food institution offering delicious meal delivery and dine-in options. Specializing in a variety of pizzas, Salerno Pizza features unique toppings such as ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and tomato. In addition to their pizza offerings, they also serve classic square, thick crust pizzas, as well as a range of appetizers and entrees including buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks, French fries, chicken dishes, and seafood options like shrimp in garlic and wine sauce. Salerno Pizza is known for their White Pie, a sauceless pie with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, as well as their generous portions and affordable deals. With convenient curbside pickup and payment options including credit cards, Salerno Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Astoria looking for a satisfying and tasty meal.