Stamp purchasing in West Caldwell, New Jersey

Welcome to Bagelwich Bagel Bakery, your go-to destination for freshly made bagels and delicious deli sandwiches in West Caldwell, New Jersey. Located conveniently at 673 Bloomfield Avenue, our bakery is dedicated to serving the community with a delightful selection of bagels, wraps, and paninis, all crafted with the finest ingredients to ensure the highest quality and taste. At Bagelwich Bagel Bakery, we believe in rewarding our loyal customers. Join our loyalty program by getting your card scanned by the cashier with every purchase of $5 or more. Accumulate one stamp per visit and enjoy exclusive rewards! Signing up is easy—use your phone number and email to receive a text with a 4-digit confirmation number to recover your card anytime.