Bent Prop Pub

"The atmosphere was great. We both had fish and it was amazing. Everyone there was very friendly."

"My husband and I dined here over the weekend. This was our first time here. On a Saturday evening at 7:30 the place was fairly open with plenty of seating. We sat in the bar at a high top table. Service was quick with getting drinks and she came and took an appetizer order. We got a giant hot pretzel that was piping hot and so good. Our food came out very hot. I got the chicken quesadillas and it was so good. Freshly made, and huge! My husband got the chicken wrap with frys and they were hot, and crispy. The bill with tip came out to about $60. We will definitely be back."

"We found this place while traveling. It was decent. Pretty busy too. My burger was a little overcooked but they were busy so I can understand that."

"I dined at Bent Prop today and wanted to share my experience. While the overall meal was okay, there were a few aspects that left me disappointed. One particular issue that bothered me was their substitution policy. The Filet Mignon came with mashed potatoes and vegetables, but I preferred having fries and a side caesar salad instead. I was expecting there to be an up-charge for the side salad as is usual with most restaurants. When I got the bill, I was surprised to find out that they charged me the full price of the fries and salad as if I were ordering additional sides. It seems unfair, as I was simply substituting a side dish for another. Mashed potatoes for a different form of potato… I believe it would have been more reasonable for them to charge a fee for the salad and substitute the potatoes at no additional cost. The prices aren’t cheap to begin with. Spent $65 on two people with no alcohol. The food was just okay, definitely not worth the price. Nothing to write home about. Not bad but not good. Mediocre at best. The pizza was extremely greasy. I included photos of our dishes (along with some friends’ dishes) and our receipt. Although the water view was nice, I won’t be returning."

"Coldwater could use more flavor and customer service like they've got at the Bent Prop. We rarely make it out there, but have declared it far superior to our other regular spots in branch county. The food was ALL delicious, the pretzel was the size of my face and actually came with beer cheese instead of nacho cheese. The staff checked in on us frequently and always with a smile. There were lots of staff buzzing around interacting with their tables. And the people there all seemed very happy to be there. It's just a great ambiance to be around cheerful people and great food with a beautiful lake view right next to you, and especially when they have a live band playing! 10/10 recommend the Bent Prop! We will be back very soon!"