TOP 10 Restaurant pies in Indiana

Mrs. Wick's Restaurant & Pie Shop is a beloved institution located at 100 North Cherry Street in Winchester, Indiana. Originally opened by Wick himself in honor of his wife Ruby, this full-service Bakery Cafe serves up 36 varieties of delicious pies every day. Whether you're in the mood for a classic fruit pie or a savory pot pie, Mrs. Wick's has got you covered. Breakfast is served all day, and their menu also includes famous noodles, shells, and unbaked frozen pies. If you're looking to order a custom pie, just give them a call with 1 or 2 days' notice. While their inventory changes daily, you can always count on Mrs. Wick's to provide high-quality, delicious baked goods that exceed your expectations. And if you can't make it to the restaurant in person, you can have their pies shipped straight to your doorstep for a convenient and tasty treat.

Pie Pan Restaurant & Bakery is a charming establishment located at 905 North Park Drive in Evansville, Indiana. This versatile institution offers a delightful combination of bakery treats, mouthwatering food, and a cozy dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for freshly baked pies, delicious meals, or shopping for culinary delights, Pie Pan Restaurant & Bakery has something for everyone. Come and enjoy a slice of homemade goodness in this warm and inviting setting.

O'Reilly's Irish Pub & Restaurant is a cozy and inviting establishment located in the heart of Fort Wayne, Indiana. As soon as you step inside, you are greeted with the warm ambiance of a traditional Irish pub. The menu offers a delicious selection of Irish and American cuisine, with classics such as shepherd's pie, fish and chips, and corned beef and cabbage. The bar boasts an impressive selection of beers on tap, as well as a variety of cocktails and Irish whiskeys. Whether you're looking for a place to grab a pint with friends or enjoy a hearty meal with family, O'Reilly's Irish Pub & Restaurant is the perfect spot to experience the charm and hospitality of an authentic Irish pub.

Manny's Restaurant is a cozy and welcoming eatery located at 801 West Michigan Street in New Carlisle, Indiana. Serving up delicious American comfort food, Manny's is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu featuring classic dishes like burgers, sandwiches, and homemade pies, there's something for everyone to enjoy. The friendly staff and casual atmosphere make Manny's the perfect place to grab a bite to eat with friends and family. Come dine at Manny's Restaurant and experience the warm hospitality and tasty cuisine that keeps customers coming back for more.

Michael's Italian Restaurant, located at 528 Harrison Street in Elkhart, Indiana, has been a beloved fixture in the southside Italian neighborhood since 1917. While known for their delicious thin-crust pizzas, the menu offers much more than just pizza. Locals rave about the EBA (Everything But Anchovies) pizza, topped with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers. For a spicy twist, try the "Plummers" pie with jalapenos instead of green peppers. With a name like "That's Amore," you know you're in for a treat. In addition to the Italian fare, the Iavagnilio family also opened "Rico's at the Bulldog," a restaurant and bar serving American cuisine with a focus on mouthwatering burgers. For more information, visit ricoselkhart.com.

The Shipshewana Auction Restaurant is a charming dining establishment located in Shipshewana, Indiana. Situated at 345 South Van Buren Street, this restaurant offers a unique experience for visitors looking to enjoy delicious meals in a cozy atmosphere. Known for its hearty Amish-style dishes and homemade pies, the Shipshewana Auction Restaurant is a popular choice among locals and tourists alike. Whether you're stopping by for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a filling dinner, this restaurant is sure to please your taste buds. With friendly service and a welcoming ambiance, the Shipshewana Auction Restaurant is a must-visit destination for anyone craving comfort food in the heart of Amish country.

Aunt Mable's Fried Pies is a charming eatery located at 435 South Van Buren Street in Shipshewana, Indiana. Specializing in delicious homemade fried pies, this cozy restaurant offers a variety of sweet and savory options to satisfy any craving. Guests can enjoy a warm and welcoming atmosphere while indulging in Aunt Mable's famous pies made with love and care. Whether you're looking for a tasty treat or a hearty meal, Aunt Mable's Fried Pies is the perfect spot to enjoy a delightful dining experience in Shipshewana.

Wise Pies is a popular restaurant located at 9 South 6th Street in Terre Haute, Indiana. Specializing in delicious pies, this institution offers a wide variety of savory and sweet options for customers to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a quick meal takeaway or a cozy dining experience, Wise Pies has something for everyone. Come visit us and indulge in our mouthwatering pies made with fresh, quality ingredients.

Grand Traverse Pie Company is a bakery, restaurant, and store located at 75 North 3rd Street in Terre Haute, Indiana. This is the only Grand Traverse Pie shop in Indiana, offering fresh, homemade pies every day. The shop is conveniently located near the Interstate, Indiana State University, and the Courthouse. In addition to pies, they also serve a full breakfast, lunch, and dinner menu including pot pies, quiche, beef pasties, sandwiches, soups, salads, and more. Unique catering options, such as boxed lunches, are also available. The comfortable dining room offers complimentary WiFi for guests. The institution is actively involved in hosting community activities and proudly supports the Vigo County Schools Backpack Program. Come for the pie, stay for the food at Grand Traverse Pie Company in Terre Haute!

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Meadows is a charming institution located at 3 The Meadows in Terre Haute, Indiana, United States. This versatile establishment offers a unique combination of bakery, food, restaurant, and store services. For the month of April, indulge in our delectable Lemon Cheesecake, Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies, available for a limited time only.

Two Guys Pies is a popular food institution located at 55 East Main Street in Danville, Indiana, United States. Specializing in delicious pizzas and other mouth-watering dishes, Two Guys Pies is the perfect spot for any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting an office function, or just craving some tasty food, Two Guys Pies has got you covered. The restaurant also has a sister establishment in the same building that can accommodate large parties and events. You can even order drinks and food from the Two Guys Pies menu at this location. With the capacity to handle large orders for parties and meetings, Two Guys Pies is the go-to spot for all your catering needs.

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 100 West Union Street in Paragon, Indiana. Specializing in delicious tomato pies and mouthwatering pizza creations, this eatery offers a unique and satisfying dining experience for all pizza lovers. The casual atmosphere and friendly service make it the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends and family. Whether you're in the mood for a classic margherita pizza or a specialty pie loaded with fresh toppings, Tomato Pie Pizza Joint has something for everyone. Come visit us and taste the difference for yourself!

Country Kettle Restaurant is a charming eatery located at 1704 South Heaton Street in Knox, Indiana. Known for its delicious homestyle cooking and warm, welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a menu featuring classic American dishes such as fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and homemade pies, Country Kettle Restaurant offers a taste of comfort and nostalgia in every bite. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a comforting dinner, this restaurant is sure to hit the spot. Come dine with us and experience the flavors of home at Country Kettle Restaurant.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Avon is a cozy establishment located at 121 Avon Village Parkway in Avon, Indiana. This institution offers a wide range of freshly baked goods, hearty meals, and delicious treats. From Lemon Cheesecake to Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies, there is something for everyone to enjoy. At MCL Restaurant & Bakery Avon, all the food is made in-house from scratch using their famously flaky pie dough, gravies, and dumplings in chicken & noodles. The belief is that homemade food tastes better and is more nourishing, which is why they take pride in preparing everything with care and attention to detail.

Pies & Pints in Carmel, IN is a charming restaurant located at 14550 Clay Terrace Boulevard. This cozy eatery offers a delectable menu featuring a variety of savory pies and a wide selection of craft beers on tap. Whether you're in the mood for a classic meat pie or a unique vegetarian option, Pies & Pints has something for everyone. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal with family and friends. Visit Pies & Pints in Carmel for a memorable dining experience in Indiana.

Sam’s Square Pie is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 2829 East 10th Street in Indianapolis, Indiana. Known for their delicious square-shaped pies, this eatery offers a unique and satisfying dining experience. Whether you choose to dine in, take your meal to go, or have it delivered straight to your door, Sam’s Square Pie is sure to leave you craving more. With a menu full of mouthwatering options, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere, this institution is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the Indianapolis area.

Country Family Restaurant is a cozy dining establishment located at 410 West Main Street in North Manchester, Indiana. As its name suggests, this restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that is perfect for families looking for a delicious meal. Serving up classic American comfort food, Country Family Restaurant is known for its hearty portions, friendly service, and affordable prices. Whether you're craving a juicy burger, a plate of crispy fried chicken, or a slice of homemade pie, this restaurant has something for everyone. Come on in and experience the welcoming hospitality and mouthwatering dishes that make Country Family Restaurant a beloved dining destination in North Manchester.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Southside is a charming establishment located at 3630 South East Street in Indianapolis, Indiana. This institution offers a delightful combination of bakery, food, restaurant, and store all in one convenient location. For a limited time in April, indulge in their special offerings such as Lemon Cheesecake, Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies. These treats are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving for more.

The American Table Family Restaurant of Vincennes is a cozy and welcoming dining establishment located at 1500 Willow Street in Vincennes, Indiana. This family-friendly restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring classic American dishes that are sure to satisfy every appetite. Whether you're craving a hearty burger, a comforting bowl of soup, or a delicious slice of pie for dessert, American Table has something for everyone. With its friendly staff and inviting atmosphere, American Table is the perfect spot for a casual meal with loved ones or a quick bite to eat while exploring Vincennes. Come experience the warm hospitality and delicious food that make American Table a beloved dining destination in the heart of Indiana.

Kathy Jo's Chatterbox Restaurant is a cozy and inviting dining establishment located at 208 North Alexander Street in Carlisle, Indiana, United States. Known for its friendly atmosphere and delicious comfort food, this restaurant is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The menu features a variety of classic American dishes, including burgers, sandwiches, and homemade pies. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal with friends, Kathy Jo's Chatterbox Restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy good food and great conversation.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Carmel is a beloved institution located at 1390 Keystone Way in Carmel, Indiana, United States. This versatile establishment offers a variety of delicious options including bakery items, food, and restaurant dishes. For a limited time in April, guests can enjoy special treats such as Lemon Cheesecake, Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies.

Pies & Pints in Noblesville, IN is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 13901 Town Center Boulevard. Specializing in delicious pies and a wide selection of craft beers, this establishment offers a unique dining experience for locals and visitors alike. With a relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff, Pies & Pints is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty meal and unwind with friends or family. Whether you're craving a savory pie or a refreshing pint, this restaurant has something for everyone to enjoy. Come and indulge in a delightful culinary experience at Pies & Pints in Noblesville, Indiana.

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery is a beloved institution located at 13316 Tegler Drive in Noblesville, Indiana, United States. This establishment is a one-stop shop for delicious baked goods, hearty meals, and a cozy dining experience. Whether you're craving a warm slice of pie, a hearty breakfast, or a satisfying sandwich, Perkins Restaurant & Bakery has something for everyone. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, this institution is the perfect place to enjoy a meal with family and friends. Come visit Perkins Restaurant & Bakery for a delightful dining experience that will leave you coming back for more.

O'Reilly's Irish Pub & Restaurant is a cozy and welcoming establishment located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, Indiana. Situated at 36 South Pennsylvania Street, this Irish pub offers a traditional and authentic experience with a modern twist. With its warm and inviting atmosphere, O'Reilly's is the perfect spot to grab a pint of Guinness and enjoy classic Irish fare. From hearty stews and fish and chips to tasty shepherd's pie and Irish soda bread, the menu at O'Reilly's is sure to satisfy any craving.

Dom's Pie Shop is a cozy and inviting restaurant located on North Wells Street in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Specializing in delicious homemade pies, this charming institution offers a wide variety of sweet and savory options to satisfy every craving. From classic apple and cherry pies to unique creations like s'mores and key lime, there is something for everyone at Dom's Pie Shop. Whether you're looking for a tasty treat to enjoy on the go or a comforting meal to share with friends and family, this beloved eatery is sure to become a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Come taste the love and care put into every pie at Dom's Pie Shop.

Be Happy Pie Company - West is a cozy bakery, food store, and restaurant located at 2818 Mount Vernon Avenue in Evansville, Indiana. Known for their delicious pies and baked goods, this institution is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect place to enjoy a sweet treat or a savory meal. Whether you're looking for a slice of homemade pie or a hearty sandwich, Be Happy Pie Company - West has something for everyone. Come in and experience the joy of good food and friendly service at this charming establishment.

Cecil's Slice Of Pie is a cozy restaurant located at 630 South Adams Street in Versailles, Indiana, offering delicious homemade pies and other comfort foods. Whether you're looking for a quick meal to take away or a convenient meal delivery option, Cecil's Slice Of Pie has you covered. With a wide variety of savory and sweet pies to choose from, as well as other classic dishes, this establishment is sure to satisfy your cravings. Stop by Cecil's Slice Of Pie for a taste of homemade goodness in the heart of Versailles.

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen is a charming bakery, food establishment, restaurant, and store located at 3113 Blackiston Mill Road in New Albany, Indiana, United States. Indulge in delicious, handcrafted ice cream and freshly baked pies made with love and care. From classic flavors to unique creations, there is something for everyone to enjoy at this delightful institution. Whether you're looking for a sweet treat to satisfy your cravings or a gift for a special occasion, Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen has you covered. Visit us today and experience the joy of homemade desserts at its finest.

Mom's Country Kitchen is a cozy and welcoming restaurant located in Reynolds, Indiana. Situated at 401 East 2nd Street, this charming eatery offers delicious home-cooked meals in a warm and inviting atmosphere. From hearty breakfasts to savory lunches and dinners, Mom's Country Kitchen serves up traditional American fare with a touch of love and care in every dish. Whether you're craving fluffy pancakes, crispy fried chicken, or a slice of homemade pie, this institution is sure to satisfy your comfort food cravings. Come experience the taste of home at Mom's Country Kitchen.

Bello's Pizza is a beloved restaurant located at 216 East Main Street in Madison, Indiana. Specializing in delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, Bello's Pizza offers a wide variety of options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Bello's Pizza is the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a gourmet specialty pie, Bello's Pizza has something for everyone to enjoy. Visit us today and experience the mouthwatering flavors that have made us a local favorite in Madison.