Specialty food in Islamorada, Florida

The Italian Food Company is a bar, restaurant, and food institution located at 82779 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, United States. We specialize in authentic Italian cuisine, including regional Neapolitan and Roman pizzas, pasta dishes, delicious entrees and appetizers, desserts, and more. Our Key Largo and Islamorada locations offer uniquely beautiful settings that will transport you to Italy in the Florida Keys. Host your special occasions with us, including wedding rehearsals, anniversaries, birthdays, and milestone celebrations. Auguri! Our pantry is fully stocked with kitchen essentials so you can elevate your own recipes at home. Come experience the taste of Italy at the Italian Food Company.

Marathon Bagel Co in Islamorada, Florida is the first authentic bagel store in the Florida Keys, offering over 12 different bagel flavors and daily specialty bagels. Choose from a variety of sweet and savory specialty cream cheeses to top your bagel. Our bagels are 14% protein with no added fat or oil, ensuring a delicious and healthy option for breakfast or lunch. Try our Nova Lox and Whitefish Salad from Acme Fish Company, or enjoy sandwiches made with chorizo from a family in Newark, NJ with a 60-year-old recipe. Visit us at 86701 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, or at our location in Marathon at 11090 Overseas Highway.

The Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie Lady is a charming food and grocery store located at 81868 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. This unique institution offers a wide variety of fresh produce, gourmet snacks, and specialty items. Visitors can also indulge in the famous Key Lime Pie made by the talented Key Lime Pie Lady herself. Whether you're looking for a quick snack, a delicious dessert, or some local groceries, The Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie Lady has something for everyone. Come visit this hidden gem and experience the flavors of the Florida Keys!

Chef Michael's, located at 81671 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, is a renowned restaurant offering a unique dining experience. With chefs who have honed their skills in top restaurants around the world, Chef Michael's presents a culinary vision that is sure to impress you and your guests. Our dedicated wait and bar staff are committed to ensuring that you have a fantastic dining experience. In addition to our restaurant, Chef Michael's also offers off-premise catering services for a variety of events, including private parties, weddings, business lunches, and more. We take pride in sourcing our ingredients from local waters and farms, supporting sustainable practices and serving the freshest, highest quality dishes.

Bayside Gourmet is a charming bakery, cafe, food store, and restaurant located at 82758 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. Situated on the waterfront, this institution offers a delightful dining experience with a picturesque view of the bay. From freshly baked pastries and gourmet sandwiches to delicious seafood dishes and specialty groceries, Bayside Gourmet has something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal with friends and family, this establishment is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious food in a beautiful setting.

El Framboyan Cuban Cuisine is a vibrant and authentic Cuban restaurant located at 82751 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. Our menu features traditional Cuban dishes with a modern twist, prepared using fresh and high-quality ingredients. From classic dishes like Ropa Vieja and Cuban sandwiches to flavorful seafood options and refreshing mojitos, our restaurant offers a taste of Cuba right in the heart of Florida Keys. Come experience the lively atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious flavors of El Framboyan Cuban Cuisine.

Island Grill, located at 85501 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, is a popular bar and restaurant known for its award-winning menu, live entertainment, and beautiful waterfront atmosphere. Specializing in fresh seafood, premium hand-cut steaks, and regional specialties, Island Grill is a favorite Florida Keys banquet destination, perfect for wedding rehearsals and receptions. With rave reviews from satisfied customers on Google, Island Grill invites you to share your own experience with them. From their famous Tuna Nachos to the Catch of the Day, their menu offers a variety of delicious options. Whether you're a tourist or a local, Island Grill is the ideal spot to enjoy casual dining and celebrate special moments in true Florida Keys style.

Rain Barrel Village, located at 86700 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, is a unique institution that combines an art gallery, park, store, and tourist attraction all in one. For over 40 years, it has been a popular destination for both tourists and locals, offering a tropical oasis filled with specialty shops, galleries, and boutiques showcasing local art, handmade crafts, custom jewelry, fashionable resort wear, and unique souvenirs. One of the main attractions at Rain Barrel Village is Betsy the Lobster, a 30-foot-tall, 40-foot-long sculpture that serves as a symbol of Florida Keys wildlife. Visitors can't resist taking a picture with this iconic landmark, making it one of the most photographed spots in the Florida Keys.

Martinis Fine Wine & Spirits is a premier liquor store located at 81650 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. With a wide selection of fine wines, spirits, and craft beers, this store is a paradise for connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike. Whether you're looking for a rare vintage, a special gift, or just stocking up for a party, Martinis Fine Wine & Spirits has everything you need. The knowledgeable staff is always on hand to offer recommendations and assistance, making your shopping experience a breeze. Visit Martinis Fine Wine & Spirits and elevate your beverage game today.

Marker 88 is a popular bar and restaurant located at 88000 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. Known for its delicious food and refreshing drinks, Marker 88 offers a unique dining experience with stunning views of the ocean. In addition to their mouth-watering dishes, Marker 88 also has a boutique where guests can purchase souvenirs such as t-shirts, hats, craft sodas, and their famous key lime pie. Forgot to pick up a souvenir during your visit? Don't worry, you can shop online and have it shipped to you. Make your trip to the Florida Keys unforgettable with a visit to Marker 88.

Nikai Sushi is a top-rated Japanese restaurant located at 81801 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. Known for serving the best sushi and Japanese cuisine in Islamorada, Nikai offers a wide variety of traditional favorites as well as innovative new dishes. The menu includes nigiri, sashimi, specialty rolls, and other delicious Japanese-inspired dishes. The chefs at Nikai use fresh, locally sourced ingredients to create a unique dining experience that combines the flavors of the Far East with the tropical vibes of the Florida Keys. In addition to their exceptional food, Nikai also offers a creative bar program featuring sake, craft cocktails, and beers. Guests can enjoy dishes like tuna with scallion and eel sauce, crispy wonton chips, and a variety of sushi and sashimi options. For those looking to try a bit of everything, Nikai offers a Chef's Tasting Menu with multiple courses featuring seasonal seafood and produce. The restaurant also has a selection of delicious desserts and a wide range of sake options for guests to enjoy. Whether you're a sushi lover or just looking to try something new, Nikai Sushi is the perfect place to experience the best of Japanese cuisine in Islamorada.

Mia Cucina is a food institution located at 81801 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, United States. Nestled within the luxurious Cheeca Lodge & Spa, Mia Cucina offers a dining experience like no other. With turquoise waters, towering palms, and calm breezes surrounding you, you can indulge in delicious cuisine while soaking up the laid-back lifestyle of Islamorada. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner overlooking the ocean or a casual lunch by the pool, Mia Cucina has something for everyone. From fresh seafood to gourmet pizzas, our menu is sure to satisfy even the most discerning palate. Come and experience the perfect blend of leisure and luxury at Mia Cucina.

Cafe Cubano Cuban Cuisine is a charming and authentic eatery located at 74052 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida. This cozy cafe offers a taste of Cuba with its flavorful and traditional Cuban dishes. From classic Cuban sandwiches to hearty ropa vieja and savory picadillo, Cafe Cubano serves up a delicious array of dishes that will transport you to the streets of Havana. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make this cafe a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Cuban cuisine in the heart of the Florida Keys.

Coastal Cup and Lounge is a vibrant institution located at 80001 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, offering a unique blend of bar, cafe, food, night club, restaurant, and store experiences. Effortless island style is showcased in our Florida Keys rooms and suites, allowing guests to immerse themselves in authentic Keys life. Enjoy island-inspired flavors and legendary cocktails while taking in stunning sea views. Our Keys venues provide the perfect setting for any gathering, whether it's a casual meal or a night out on the town. Indulge in cuisine rooted in the traditions of the Florida Keys at ReelCatch, Coastal Cup, or Tiki Bar, where classic burgers, succulent seafood, custom-blended treats, and top-shelf spirits await. Be sure to check out our calendar of authentic island experiences happening at Amara Cay Resort. Experience the best of the Florida Keys at Coastal Cup and Lounge.