The Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie Lady

"Local ranked the key lime pie lady inside of The Trading Post second only to his grandma. We concur! Perfect graham cracker (non-greasy) crust, excellent filling. Definitely a winner!"

"5.0 Key lime Square! Pie is devine. Little grocery store. Go to back left cooler. I’m sure I’ll crave this rest of my life."

"We tried 4 key lime pies while in the keys and this was by far the best!!! Afterwards, we wished we had only had this version as none of the others compared! Perfectly balanced sweet and tart, amazing crust. Absolutely delicious!!!"

"*photos submitted and experience are from December of 2020* When I visited the keys around a year ago, I tried every key lime pie and this was the only one I enjoyed. The crust was perfectly crisp, and the filling was flavorful and smooth. It felt like the only key lime pie in the keys that didn’t cut corners. If I could ship one of these pies to NYC without it costing like $100 then I definitely would. 10/10, would definitely recommend."

"First caught sight of this on Google Maps as 'Key Lime Pie Lady,' but it's actually a product that is sold at this trading post. There is also a coffee shop, burrito shop, boutiques in the same lot. They looked really good too, but I was too stuffed to get anything else. I just had some beers and tacos at Jaliscos Tacos 2 at the Florida Keys Brewing Company about a 10 minute walk across the street. Super worth it by the way! Great brewery and food truck!! So, I needed something sweet and saw this on the Googs. I really wanted a Chocolate Key Lime Pie Slice, but they were unfortunately out! So, I got the Chocolate Key Lime Bar instead. Still refreshing and had the crust mixed in so I was happy with that. Aside from my sweet tooth, this is a pretty well stocked post with ready-to-eat meals and necisities as well."