Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill - BBQ 4445 Highway 411, Madisonville, TN 37354

"After reading all of the reviews I was anticipating a delicious meal.. Definitely not what we got.. When walking in, it is an extremely dry and unwelcoming environmen it is silent with white walls, white floors, white ceilings, with white tables and white plastic chairs.. very uninviting. I took my two young kids to go get some food and started off trying to order a sweet tea but they don't have sweet tea (or were out of it) understandable.. got to looking at the menu and realized that there is no kid menu. I had to order a full size $9 spaghetti for my 3-year-old that is going to eat three bites and tell me he's full.. But when the spaghetti came out it is noodles with canned pasta sauce and some melted cheese on top.. Zero meat and Zero flavor. I got a smoked bologna sandwich and french fries that had Zero flavor.. cost $12.. And my daughter ordered a barbecue chicken pizza that was $17 and consisted of four slices that maybe a chicken leg worth of meat sprinkled on the entirety of the pizza.. Needless to say, we will definitely not be returned customers. Quantity, quality, and pricing are all a long way away from what you get. Do not let the reviews fool you as they did us. This place is horrible."

"This has got to be by far the WORST place I've ever eaten at!! As soon as we sat down the waitress told us they had NO SWEET TEA! Wth this is the south. I proceeded to order a water and corona with lime and again the waitress said we don't have lime for your corona disappointedly I still ordered a corona. We proceeded to order a appetizer of fried green tomatoes when they came to our table they were served on a paper plate with plastic silverware. I ordered 10 wings naked and they were terrible loaded down with salt and my wife ordered western rolls which were frozen and still cold on the inside all of which was served on "yep u gessed it paper plates and plastic silverware" the couple next to us said it was their 1st time being there like us and would NOT be back they said their food was terrible also! Definitely NOT worth the 50 bucks I spent and we'll NOT be returning"

"This was like home for me! Been along time since I have had a GREAT Philly like home. The Alfredo was creamy and seasoned just right and the Chicken Tender wrap was HUGE!!! all could easily be split with two people so the pricing to me is awesome for the amount of food you get! Came back and ordered Wings, Fish, and an Italian Hoagie today. All so far have been Truly Delicious!!! We will be regulars. one more IMPORTANT thing the staff and owner make you feel like family and are always smiling. 10/10 see y'all soon!!!"

"The owner Jay is top notch and his food is amazing and the quantity you receive is more than enough to fill your stomach. My granddaughter sure loves his bbq and his pizza will more than fill you up with all the toppings he uses so stop by and give him a try and his smoked bologna sandwich is the best I’ve ever had."

"First time going here today and I will say we were VERY pleased. The ladies up front were very nice and welcoming! The food was fresh, hot and delicious and The fried green tomatoes were amazing! Don’t listen to the bad reviews on here, considering it’s a freshly opened business there will obviously be kinks until things get settled down. People in Madisonville are just bitter… DON’T KNOCK IT TILL YOU TRY IT!"