Game On 465 New York 25A, Miller Place, NY 11764

"Long Island doesn’t have as many retro game stores as I’d like, but the ones we do have are fantastic and Game On is no exception. It’s a fairly small store with not as much stock as some other stores, but it makes up for the fact that the employees are super friendly and courteous. They’re always smiling and happy to discuss anything they have for sale. I’m 100% going to keep visiting for years to come."

"Love it! Brought my kids to the arcade at smith haven mall. It was such a cool experience. The place is clean, has awesome 90s decor, and love the 80-90s music. It was really a neat place to bring my children and letting them experience what our childhood was like! Def recommend! There were old games like Mario and Sonic as well as newer ones like stranger things. Kids had a blast!"

"Truly a great store run by a great guy. I always call Game On to check what new items are in stock. One time I wanted to buy a Dreamcast, and not only did he have the specific version (revision 0) that I wanted, but he also called the other Game On location to hold it for me. Another time I called and asked about the Grinch Dreamcast game that I saw posted on the Facebook page. I planned on going later in the week and when I finally arrived, he went in the back room and already had it ready for me. It’s the little details that show how much he appreciates his customers. I also went to the opening of the Patchogue location and when I accidentally bought the wrong color Yoshi plush, I went back in and he let me switch it with no issues. Another thing that sets Game On apart from other gaming stores is the sheer variety of games and consoles they have. I’ve seen everything from the 3DO to the NeoGeo CD to even the Virtual Boy! I highly recommend that you visit any of the three store locations because you will always be impressed with what they have in stock. All consoles and games are refurbished to a Like New Quality. There’s also Amiibos, Skylanders, Disney Infinity figures and Funko Pops for any of you figurine collectors out there. They even have old school gaming magazines and guide books in Mint Condition! Truly the Best Gaming Store on Long Island! Game On!"

"Can I just start out by saying WOW! This place is nothing short of amazing. I started out going to the miller place store location several times over the years. It’s become a tradition for my son and I to pop in when we pass by to check out some games, toys and just to see what’s new. My son even participated in an arcade art contest (Pam! Haha). We came to find out it was a lead up to this very special place carved straight out of a page of my childhood. We went for the first time 2 weeks ago and were blown away. Watching my son go from game to game was something that warmed my heart. Seeing him get joy from a true mall arcade was something I thought I’d never see happen in my life. He even ranked the games on his own little scale (Dig Dug won top honors that night haha). I chalked mall arcades up to relics of the past. But the folks over at Game On have recreated this experience flawlessly. I’ll be forever grateful for that. You’ve earned regulars for life. - John & Ryan"

"Such a a cool place to visit for any gamer of any age! I really enjoy going in and checking out what new retro game or toy Tristan has. My childhood memories of playing sega genesis and super Nintendo we’re definitely on repeat when I went in for the first time. He also has a collection of retro and vintage toys/collectibles and some retro arcade games! I highly recommend it!"