Your Bagel Cafe Kohl's Shopping Center 999 Montauk Highway, Shirley, NY 11967

"Great place to grab a belly-bomb. I make sure to stop in every time I'm back home. Definitely a turn-and-burn kind of place though. No time for the pleasantries. Order, pay, get out. Which is understandable considering any time I go in there are a lot of people. Food is great."

"Every year I fly up from Florida and stop here for my bologna sandwich! Thank you Linda for making me the best bologna on a bagel! You're a gem. I always bring a dozen back to Florida. My family loves your bagels. See you next year!"

"*Update* I just want to also specify that they DID charge me for scallion cream cheese on my bagel, but they completely forgot to put it in my bagel. Besides the other fact that they did not put onions and did not charge me for the onions since they did not hear me say the onions part. That is my fault for not being clear about wanting onions on my bagel. Me being charged for something they forgot to put in my bagel is why I wrote this review. If it was just about the 1 item they never charged me for, I wouldn't have written a review in the first place. I appreciate the owner responding to my review, but they totally ignored my main concern that I wrote twice in my long review, which is why I decided to update my review to clarify my concerns. *Original post*: I have been going to this bagel shop for a couple of years already and I really love their bagels. The only problem I have with them is that I've had my order wrong multiple times already. Maybe it's my fault that they didn't hear me say something, but I swear I do say it and see it being written down. However, today was really upsetting because I came in when it wasn't busy and ordered my toasted poppy seed bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox with onions on them, a large home fries order, and a small bottle of coke. I only got my toasted poppy seed bagel with just lox, my home fries, and drink. I had to go back because I paid almost $20 dollars, so I know I most likely got charged for the cream cheese. I went back to the counter and ended up feeling bad because they didn't hear me say onions but didn't address the cream cheese portion. They fixed it and gave it to me, but because I feel bad, I questioned the counter person who worked on my order about what I paid for in the first place. It turns out, I only didn't pay for the onions which I asked if I could pay for that and she said no its okay. I don't always go back in to ask my order to be fixed since usually I already left the store, but when I do, I just end up feeling like maybe it's all my fault that it's wrong, that I didn't state what I wanted. But that's why I wanted to know what I paid this time. I just don't understand how they forgot the cream cheese in my bagel, especially if they knew what they charged me. I understand the onion part because they said they didn't hear me, so maybe I didn't say it and didn't remember that, so that is my fault. So because of this experience, I just am very upset because I always come back even if my order isn't right, but with today's experience, I don't think I will because it's happened multiple times already. I understand that things can get super busy, because I've been to this store when it's been really hectic which is understandable if my order maybe gets messed up. But, it wasn't even busy when I went in today, so that's why I'm quite upset. I am glad that the person who took my order did fix my order, specified that she didn't hear me say onions, and help me clarify what I paid for. The food is always tasting great, but I am still upset over this experience."

"This place NEVER disappoints! Employees are friendly and always greats me with a smile. My food always comes out in a timely matter and hot and the place is always clean. They remember you and make you feel welcomed! I usually get breakfast but I HIGHLY recommend!"

"My mom and I visit this bagel store every Thursday morning and order the same egg sandwiches. We love the staff! They are very friendly and kind. They work hard and it shows. The bagels are consistently good, I’ve never had a bad one ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"