Pizza 23 West 3915 New York 23, West Oneonta, NY 13861

"Literally the best place ever. Their staff was great, the food was great. The atmosphere was great! I love that it's a chief bar. Big fan!!!"

"Great food & drinks! We had pizza & fried ravioli. The pizza was to die for! Top notch services. The bartender was super friendly and made delicious drinks. He gave us a whole history of the town. We went with our baseball team and families. They were able to accommodate all of us all and made us feel very welcome. They even had a sign on the door to welcome us."

"Owner is very rude to his staff and customers. Not to mention the prices are outlandish, especially for locals who are over half your business the rest of the year you’re not catering to baseball people. Spent well over $80 on pizzas, wings and fried ravioli, to never receive $14 fried ravioli and when I called it in they called me a liar and accused me of trying to scam them out of money. Go to Nina’s on Main Street Oneonta. They are much nicer, cheaper, and their food is much more delicious. 23 thinks he makes Michelin star food when it’s the same taste as generic Pizza Hut or dominos."

"If you're coming to Oneonta and playing in the Cooperstown tournaments this is one of the few places that you could rent out for the whole team and their family members. The owners knew exactly what they were doing and have it down to a science. All the food orders were taken ahead of time, placed on their own separate table, and everybody was able to serve themselves. True family style as it should be. At the end of the meals each family is then given their own separate check which certainly helps avoid any conflicts come bill time. Highly recommend."

"Amazing staff, great place for a team party while visiting Cooperstown. Penny was so organized that we ended up doing the pizza party package delivery the night of opening ceremonies too! Would definitely recommend this place!"