Stone Creek Inn 405 Montauk Highway, East Quogue, NY 11942

"I took my Fiance here for her birthday last week. We walked in and were not welcomed very nicely, our server was extremely rude and kept rolling her eyes at us. She did not have a name tag and did not introduce herself. She hardly checked on us, did not refill our waters even once, did not make any eye contact, rushed the check and brought us cold food and desert. I also informed her I had a peanut allergy and she did not seem to take it seriously, however I couldn’t help but overhear that a woman sitting at the table across from us also had a peanut allergy and I heard her say “let me tell the chef” she didn’t say that to me. I was also very sick in the middle of the night after eating dinner. Coincidence? You tell me. Will never go back and would not recommend to anyone I care about. She absolutely ruined the night for us."

"Celebrated a friend’s birthday here and we all met at the bar to have drinks first. Bartender made a mean Cosmo and the place had a good vibe. It was a Friday night, so everyone was in a good mood. We were seated for dinner pretty quick and I ordered the steak depicted below. The food was delicious, I had shared an appetizer with my boyfriend, and we had some dessert with strawberries in it, and it was delicious. Sorry, I forgot to take pictures of those two items but at least I captured the main course. Would definitely come back and highly recommend!"

"This restaurant is amazing!! I rarely write reviews but I had to for Stone Creek Inn because the food is so good and the staff is so friendly. My favorite dish is their tiny cheese ravioli, but the tuna crispy rice is a close second. 100% do not miss out."

"This is a review for a small dinner I had catered by Stone Creek Inn. I can’t say enough how perfect our experience was! Kory managed our reservation flawlessly and Chef Zuzi’s food was amazing! The staff has impeccable timing and the service was seamless. I highly, highly recommend them! And for sure, the restaurant is a truly wonderful dining experience as well!"

"A fantastic fine dining experience. Food and service are top notch. For appetizers, we had fresh ceviche and a beautifully prepared lobster salad. The striped bass and porchetta (pictured) were delicious. My folks even paid the bill. A great night indeed!"