Home
Sign In
Guide > Restaurant in New York > Flynn's Fire Island

Flynn's Fire Island,

1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770

● Closed
4 359
Advertisements
Hours open Photos Contact Us About Us Reviews Add Review

About Us

Welcome to Flynn's Fire Island, a beloved culinary destination nestled at 1 Cayuga Street on the beautiful Fire Island, New York. Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and delectable cuisine, Flynn's Fire Island offers an unforgettable dining experience for locals and visitors alike. Our restaurant is a perfect blend of casual elegance and island charm, where guests can savor mouthwatering dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for classic seafood, succulent steaks, or innovative vegetarian options, our diverse menu is designed to delight every palate. Relax with a refreshing cocktail on our scenic outdoor patio or enjoy the lively ambiance indoors. At Flynn's Fire Island, we pride ourselves on exceptional service and creating memorable moments for every guest. Join us for a delightful meal and discover why Flynn's is a cherished gem on Fire Island.

Advertisements
Advertisements

You might also consider

Four Brothers Pizza Inn
4.1
5952 N Elm Ave, Millerton, NY 12546, United States
Taro's
4.4
18 Main St, Millerton, NY 12546, United States
Church Street Deli & Pizza
4.5
1677 County Rte 7A, Copake, NY 12516, United States

Hours open

Monday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Tuesday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Wednesday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Thursday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Friday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Saturday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Sunday:

12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Advertisements

You might also consider

Tower Pizza
4.4
2947 Church St, Pine Plains, NY 12567, United States
Santo Pizzeria & Ristorante
4.5
5094 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501, United States
Four Brothers Pizza Inn
4.3
4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501, United States

Photos

  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
  • Photo of Flynn's Fire Island - 1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, NY 11770, USA
Advertisements

You might also consider

Four Brothers Pizza Inn
4.3
2828 NY-23, Hillsdale, NY 12529, United States
3 Brothers Pizza
4.4
6270 NY-82, Stanfordville, NY 12581, United States
Tommy B's Slice Shop
4.9
1817 NY-23, Craryville, NY 12521, United States

Contact Us

Direction
1 Cayuga Street, Fire Island, New York 11770, United States
631-583-5000
flynnsfireislandny.com
Call Website
Advertisements

You might also consider

High Falls Pizzeria & Taphouse
4.3
94 Main St, Philmont, NY 12565, United States
JoJo's Pizzeria
4.5
1015 NY-82, Ancram, NY 12502, United States
Gabriel's Pizza & Grill
4.4
94 Main St, Philmont, NY 12565, United States

Reviews

New Review
Rating (required):
Advertisements
Candra Winston:
5

"Delicious food for such an amazing price. On the water and live music. Musician was great and made atmosphere so light and comfortable. Good time!!!"

almost 10 months ago
RD Ritz:
4

"Have been going to Flynn’s for over 30 years. Just a magnificent setting, and the food is very good. Tuesday evening bar entertainer was terrific. Just leaving this review because unhappy with experience during “Happy Hour” in bar yesterday. We were two couples who arrived alittle after the 5 pm start. Asked hostess if could do happy hour in restaurant as wanted dinner as well. She said only the bar area which was fine with us. She escorted us to our table and placed the 1/2 price happy hour menu and regular dinner menus on table. Ordered some half price apps and drinks which we believed to be half priced. After dinner when check arrived we saw we had been charged full price for all the specialty drinks we ordered. Only my husbands wine half price. Called the waiter over and asked if mistake. He said “only certain mixed drinks half price.” When he walked away I saw in fine print “select drinks” half price on Happy Hour menu. When he came to pick up our credit card I asked him which mixed drinks half price and he pointed to several above the area we ordered from. I mentioned to him I know I had gotten some of those same drinks last year from same section we ordered from and they were half priced during bar Happy Hour. He then told me they “changed” things this year. Nice to know after the fact, maybe hostess should have explained to us? Waiter?prior to our ordering. Would suggest Flynn’s do a better job marking Happy Hour menu. Feel very deceived. Their sign/advertisement says “Half price drinks” for Happy Hour, nothing about “select drinks.” Either waiter didn’t care to correct error or Flynn’s taking advantage of customers. So patron beware."

almost 11 months ago
Saurav Pandit:
5

"Had a great lunch there. It was a busy Sunday with an outdoor party going on. But the establishment is big and our family of 5 with kids found a comfortable space there. Beautiful bayside dining. Food was delicious. Our waitress informed us on “off the menu” items - I had lobster tacos that were delicious! Kids were happy about kid-friendly menu and the curly fries."

1 year ago
Simmons having fun:
5

"Had a great time at flynn's, food, and drinks a bid pricey but DJ So Dope was fabulous he played all types of music for everyone from young to older folks to enjoy."

1 year ago
Barry Maltese:
5

"There is a food choice of menu or buffet. The food was seasoned and cooked to perfection, and an enjoyable value, and included a nice dessert. The Wait Staff was kind, quick and efficient. And always greeted us with a smile. The atmosphere was friendly and inviting. And I can't wait to return. . . . .And the view was breathtaking."

almost 2 years ago
Advertisements

You might also consider

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza
4.2
7582 N Broadway, Red Hook, NY 12571, United States
Broadway Pizza
4.4
49 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583, United States
Il Cuore Pizza NY-82, Stanfordville, NY 12581, United States
4
6090 NY-82, Stanfordville, NY 12581, United States
Advertisements

People also searched for

Restaurant Cafe & Coffee Shop & Pub Car Service Food Establishment Best Steakhouses On Fire Island Casual Elegance Restaurants Casual Upscale Dining Coastal Dining Experiences Fine Dining On The Beach Fire Island Dining Fire Island Fine Dining Fire Island Ny Restaurants Fire Island Outdoor Seating Fire Island Restaurant Reviews Fresh Seafood Options Gourmet Seafood Island Atmosphere Dining Island Charm Dining Island Cuisine Ny Fire Island Eateries Nyc Seafood Options Nyc Waterfront Dining Seafood And Steak Combo Seafood Restaurants Near Me Steakhouse On Fire Island Summer Dining Destinations Summer Night Dining Waterfront Dining Nyc
Advertisements

List of local businesses, places and services in New York

⭐ business help 🔍 services ☎️phones ⌚️opening times ✍️reviews 📍 addresses, locations 🖼️ photos

© 2025 Guide.in.ua Privacy Policy