Bagel Supreme | Rutherford

"Very disappointing the last 4 times I've been there the bagels are different.... Can hardly chew thru the bottom of the bagels. These used to be the BEST bagels around.fresh, soft.... Now their stale and hard to eat. SAD"

"Best bagel place in our neighborhood. I love their scallion cheese. I even got a container to home. Their bagels are fresh and tasteful."

"The staff is nice and the bagels are enjoyable. The speed of service, however, is about as bad as it can get in a bagel shop, at times. They seem to have made the decision to have each employee see an order all the way through from taking the order to cooking it and finalizing it. So you could have everyone working on a cooked breakfast sandwiches and there is nobody at the counter until somebody finishes at the griddle station. I was there this morning at 7:15 AM and nobody welcomed or said anything to new customers until 7:23 AM. That's how poor the counter service can be. The gentleman behind me gave up and left and I was about to leave as well. I just wanted a single plain beggar with cream cheese and one of the other employees certainly could have done that while they were waiting for the other orders to cook. This is an inefficient process that plays itself out again and again. It would be easy for any consultant to come in and recommend having certain people specialize in certain stations/functions and keep one body at the counter taking orders (and fulfilling simple orders). See the photo of the four employees all doing a similar thing with nobody at the front counter. This went on for 7 minutes."

"Cute breakfast spot with tables for seating and lots of bagel and baked good options. Service was fast and friendly and the seating atmosphere was comfortable. The blueberry bagels didn't really taste like blueberry but the texture was good and the muffins were excellent."

"The place was homey and cozy. The cashier was attentive and helpful. He even helped me place my order and suggested People's favorite thing on the menu. The raisin bagel with strawberry cream cheese was warm and delicious...!! Will definitely return"