Papa Angelo's Pizzeria 6744 Northwest 39th Expressway, Bethany, OK 73008

"Went right before closing , wanted a slice but ended up getting Garlic Knots. Got them with I'm not kidding - bathing in half an inch of oil in the container."

"Feels like an old pizzaria walking in (additional parking in the rear with a backdoor entrance), been family run for many decades now and if you're lucky enough the owners will be in and you can chat with them and their deep NY accent. From what I can tell, there are no "pre-determined" pizzas, you just order your size and choose your toppings (not unlimited toppings unless you want to pay extra). They do have a pretty good two slice and a drink lunch special, however be warned, if you want extra toppings it's not only an extra charge per topping, but also PER SLICE - adds up real quick. Pizza came out fresh and piping hot, flavor was fine, but the crust didn't do anything for me."

"I had heard by people that seem to know about food, that this was the place for pizza in Bethany. When we first walked in it was pretty early and the dine in was not busy at all, but the phones were ringing constantly. That made me think my peeps were right about this place. That all changes once the food came out. First off we got some meatballs. These are just balls of meat with no seasoning and are super dense. The sauce was decent, but didn’t really stand out. Then the pizza came. We had half Pepperoni and Supreme. Not sure why they just used canned mushrooms for this, but they looked and tasted horrible. The cheese is thick and lacked flavor. The crust was the only good part of this pizza. The only reason this isn’t a worse review, the young man who was working the phones and taking dine in orders was a very pleasant and helpful person. He also brought out our food and checked on us later on. Didn’t get his name, but he deserved all the credit for at least a nice experience. This place is pricey for a hole in the wall local pizza joint that uses canned veggies on their supreme pizza. Maybe it was a bad night, but it was not great at all."

"The pizza was delicious. The crust is firm and that is how i like my pizza. They do not accept touchless payment methods such as apple pay and prefer to receive payments in cash as they give you a discount for paying in cash. The pizza is quite good and is the closest to new york style pizza as you can get in oklahoma. I recalled my experiences of having actual new york pizza in brooklyn and although this place is quite good wasnt up to par with the real deal for a couple of reasons. The pizzeria has the vibe of a true pizza establishment that had been in business of providing pizzas to the community for decades. This place reminds me of those types of pizzerias i enjoyed back in california growing up. I gave the place 5 stars but then i realized the quality doesnt quite match the quality of pizza places of smiliar price in california or new york or even other states while being on the expensive end of pricing. There were some pizzerias back in california of greater quality for less price that i recalled reminiscing and realized it doesnt do justice for other places to rate this place so highly. If inflation is the reason for pricing i have to deduct a star since if this was a place in california or new york would fall in the middle of pack for quality."

"Best pizza in OKC! The food, service, and environment is excellent! I had a meatball & black olive pizza with their homemade Reaper sauce. By far the best spicy pizza I’ve ever had. It was the real deal. The flavor was amazing and the heat had me sweating like crazy."