The Maui Cookie Lady

"It's a neat shop in Makawao with enthusiastic sales people. I wouldn't drive out there just for this place again. It's fun to check out the other shops and make a day of it to support some of the other local shops. Sadly, the cookies don't seem to live up to the hype. They're almost $10 each and turn into a very crumbly mess. Oddly the middle was undercooked, probably because they're so large. We were both turned off by the gritty texture. Not sure what that was. We really tried to enjoy it but it just didn't justify the price or the hype."

"Remember circus animal cookies from when you were a kid? The Maui Cookie Lady has combined those with the most mouthwatering hand made ice cream bar on planet earth! Whenever I land on Maui I make a beeline right to it! You can sing my praises later, go get one before they get gobbled up!"

"I placed an order online after the tragic fires in Maui in early August because I wanted to do what I could to help support the island from far away in Texas because I love Maui and all the people I've met there. I received my cookies yesterday and was pleasantly surprised with how well everything was packaged and all the little things that were done to make my package unique and special. Most importantly...EVERY cookie was delivered in tact and so scrumptious!! I will not hesitate to order from The Maui Cookie Lady again even though there are cookie bakeries on pretty much every corner of my home town. Mahalo for adding and sending extra Aloha to me."

"I’m a bit of a good critic but these are incredible. I have been ordering for years and got to visit the shop in Makawao town. I buy the large cookies for presents and everyone given too loves them. I like the small ones and Buttercitch Kisses and Pineapple passion my favorite. I also like the grown up Samoa w coconut and dark chocolate . Yummy"

"The shop was cute and all decorated. There was lots of different items to look at for sale. The cookie lady was very nice and friendly. As I was going into this store I was under the impression that the cookies would be fresh and home made in the shop. But the cookies were actually premade and in packages, shipped to the shop. The cookies were on the more pricier side. We bought 4 cookies while we were there and it was about $27."