Gus's New York Pizza

"Came here for the first time, and tried a slice of Alfredo chicken and I absolutely loved it. The cashier, Manny was very polite and even gave me a ranch for free, after I forgot to ask for one! Would highly recommend"

"Called to order a 16” that’s $19.99. Cashier named “Manny” … told us they are not preparing 16” inch and only preparing large pizza (18”) which are listed at 21.99 on their website. Manny claimed it was $35.00 and online pricing was wrong. He refused to honor online pricing. Clearly lying and acting very shady. Be careful - don’t get lied to."

"Gus's New York Pizza disappointed with bland pizza and mediocre service. The ambience was unremarkable. I wouldn't recommend it. Service, while not terrible, was also just okay. The staff did their job but didn't go above and beyond to make us feel welcome or attended to. It felt like a very transactional experience."

"The staff here are truly amazing! They're VERY courteous, helpful, and SO CARING! Seriously unbelievable, how much they care and go out of their way for us!! We've never seen anything like it, to this extreme! We've ordered twice from here now, thru 3rd party delivery,.. and had to call them, due to lack of service through the 3rd party delivery. They're very caring and responsive! HUGE SHOUTOUTS TO THE WHOLE STAFF - And specifically, to the gentlemen I had spoken with - RAN & KENNY - You two rock!!!! Pizza's are great, and we love their pizza sauce, and dough/crust they make, Ana are topped with the fresh ingredients! Their wings are monstrous and perfectly cooked, their mozzarella sticks are good with their very tasty Marinara! Let's not forget about their AWESOME SALADS! I literally crave their salads! They're fresh made, very nicely chilled and have great crunch to the lettuce, with great ranch dressing to top it with!! We're excited to dine in soonly,.. And we'll definitely be ordering for delivery again!!!!"

"Unfortunately I had never been to this place in the first few years of when it opened. I had gone across the street to another place. The other place had new owners take over and lowered the quality. So I thought I would give Gus's a try. I was wowed by how good their pizza was. The slice on top with meat was good but the bottom slice with everything on it was amazing. The crust had a crispness to it and also chewy. I definitely recommend if you go in to get the pizza with everything. Not sure if that was the correct name of pizza."