Cobby's 4348 West Chinden Boulevard, Garden City, ID 83714

"I haven't been back since July 2023 as they forgot an entire sandwich and I was too busy and tired to go back and have them fix the order. We placed an order today and they forgot an entire kids meal. Admittedly, we should have checked the order before leaving, but settled for calling them about it. They did not answer their phone after multiple calls. My husband left with the receipt to get the forgotten kids meal which should've been proof enough. I called them from my phone hoping they could make the forgotten order while he drove back with the receipt. The person who finally answered the phone stated that it's their policy to show them all the food. So I called my husband and had him drive back to get the food and return to Cobby's. When he gets there, another employee said he didn't have to bring in all the food to prove we're not trying to steal a kid sized ham sandwich and macaroni salad so we went through all the song and dance for some bored employee's entertainment. Maybe that guy has the missing ham sandwich. We won't be going back."

"This place, specifically this location, is a time capsule. It's like a lodge in the interior, like it was crafted years ago very simply and has a very unique smell. The food is amazing. Soups are stellar. Drink offerings are totally acceptable for an old sandwich shop. The salad bar is a little lacking but has the standards. Staff is nice, during a rush they get through the line of people - just not super quick. Always worth the wait though. You are always offered free chips and fruit. Sometimes they even have free logo'd 5 gallon buckets. Why? I have no clue but people were excited to take them home. They do have meeting rooms to host larger groups of people."

"This was my first time trying Cobby’s and I’m SO impressed! The gentleman who helped me was extremely kind and informative. The food is delicious and the best part is that they offer Gluten-free bread! He made sure to wipe everything down for me and it was greatly appreciated. I will absolutely be going back!"

"I use to love Coby’s but then I took a break about 3 weeks back the food was getting worse and worse. But then I came back to a new staff and the service was alright. But the sandwich was horrible. The Bacon was completely raw. I had to take it off the sandwich because I couldn’t eat it. The tomato it was pinkish white and warm and seemed like it has been sitting for a long time. Now finally for the price, i paid $13.20 for a small sandwich that was super overpriced. After this experience i am done with Coby’s it’s just really aggravating i paid that much for raw nasty sandwich."

"Did you know Cobby's has meeting rooms! We planned my son's Birthday at Cobby's. Strange place? Not hardly! We had a 9 ft long sandwich & a fantastic time! My only reason for marking one star lower was the disappearance of the phone booth! My heart is broken. Such a mainstay. The Food and Fun was AMAZING. They have 2 rooms. The 16 person is free to reserve. The 50 person room is $100 of cobby's food. We did that with the giant sandwich then enjoyed pitchers of beer & soda to supplement. The staff was kind and forthright. If you have a party or club, this is a very clear win for a meeting place. Thank you, Cobby's! My son's special day was epic!"