The Iron Pizza Company 29801 North Old Highway 95, Athol, ID 83801

"Came to town for a Football game with my sons and decided on Pizza. With different ideas of which is good, the three of us decided on the 24" pepperoni. This New York style pie had the right amount of sauce and the crust was delicious. I am surprised I could only eat one slice since my appetite was pretty big. The slices hung over the edge of the plate. Pizza was amazing and is a great breakfast this morning as I write this. Recommend"

"Pretty good pizza, a little expensive. Pretty good service. It's pretty loud inside and the outside tables have a loud ac next to them which gets annoying. Overall solid choice for dinner."

"They need serious quality control. I have tried this place 3 times and each time I’ve had poor quality food. They always make it right in the end but at their cost. Iron pizza turns out a good product when it does. I spent $90. 1 pepperoni,1 supreme, cheesy bread and order of wings. I received 9 wing in the order, 2 pepperoni pizzas(one tasted burnt one burnt) and cheesy bread(tasted burnt). They did replace the one pepperoni for a supreme. They tried to make it right but a burnt supreme was delivered. All in all poor poor quality."

"I honestly love this place! Every time I come the service, food and company is always great! A very nice selection of draft beers with a decent choice of wines as well as non- alcoholic beverages. All the pizzas are unique and full of flavor. And THE BEST WEDGE SALAD I've ever had!! ANYWHERE!! Is definitely a must when in the area."

"Stopped in on our way to Sandpoint after hearing how good it was. The parking lot was PACKED full, which is something I didn’t know was possible in Athol Idaho. Upon entry there was so much going on, it was eclectic with several different vibes yet somehow it flowed perfectly which is something I have not seen in a restaurant! One section is a pool hall/arcade, then we have bear skins and deer mounts, a psychedelic hallway to the bathroom complete with black light posters, then brewery feel in the bar. I love the intuitive design! I will say it took quite a bit of time to be helped, we were acknowledged when we walked in but not helped for 15-20mins. Our server was AWESOME though, he was very efficient and made sure we were happy/taken care of, great warm personality. We ordered the beer cheese bread as an app which was great, the cheese was def cheesin with good pull and the dough they use has great consistency. We also ordered a half “Death by Meat” and half “Gangsters Paradise” , it seemed like the pizza took FOREVVERR but both options were phenomenal! They were super busy, again I was shocked seeing so many at 1 place in Athol, but it was a full house for the entire 2 hours we were there, door dash and pickup orders non stop! I think the waits that we experienced had less to do with the actual service and more with understaffing in such a busy place. As we ordered a lava cake for dessert, live music began to set up and play which was very cool, everyone in all parts of the restaurant were smiling and having fun. This place is definitely worth the stop, I really wish i would have gotten the pizza flight, but at least it gives me an excuse to go back! Great energy, great service, great food!"