Potbelly 12 South Bemiston Avenue, Clayton, MO 63105

"Absolutely delicious! Great dining experience with amazing tasting food!!!! Pizza melt is fantastic!!!"

"Closed 40 minutes early and couldn't pick up my take out order that I paid for and tipped on. Absolutely ridiculous. If you're gonna close early, stop taking orders and cancel ones already in the system with refunds. Now I'm gonna have to jump through hoops just to get my money back."

"A person let me try their Lemon Cheesecake Cookie and it was one of the best cookies I have had in a long time. I came here just for the cookie!"

"Rating: 3.8 Stars I have had Potbelly Sandwich Shop in the past, and they make good sandwiches. This was my first experience with their Sugar Cookie. As a cookie reviewer, it is my duty to put a review online. I was given their Sugar Cookie as a thank-you gift. It was just an average sugar cookie. I much prefer sugar cookies that are soft and gooey; this was very crumbly and dried out. I am not sure that I believe that it was baked fresh since it cracked on its own from being dried out. The edges of this Sugar Cookie were the best part. Also, there was too much granulated sugar on top. I wish this place was close to the River so that I could try their sandwich more often!"

"I went to this restaurant with my friend for lunch. After we ordered our sandwiches, the staff was asking us if we want mushroom, cheese and bacon on our sandwiches. We declined bacon but ok with mushroom and cheese. Then he asked us two more times about adding bacon. I declined the offer again. I didn't check my bill when I paid for the meal. After I got home from work, I realized they charged me bacon on both sandwiches. I called the restaurant on the same day and talked to their manager. He told me to come in so he can take care of it. He did give me the refund after I swing by 2 days later. I did enjoy their sandwiches in the past. I didn't understand why they keep on ask you about adding bacon but they don't tell you it is $1.60 extra for the bacon. They also automatically add onto your bill without asking. I just don't think it is an honest practice."