Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Metairie

"Ate with the BF last night here. While setting down our two Pizzas, the server let me know that they forgot to add tomatoes on my pizza, but they already had another one correctly made in the oven for me free of charge. She also asked if I'd like to box the one she brought or the one coming out of the oven. I was absolutely starving so I chose to eat most of the one that came out with my boyfriends food. They didn't miss a beat. That's great service. Also, everyone was super friendly. I had a Margarita pizza, add mushrooms, peps, and artichoke hearts. The lack of tomatoes did make a big difference in the flavor profile, but it was still great pizza. My boyfriend ordered the prosciutto & arugula. It was delicious. I can't say I was fond of the atmosphere, but I don't like loud or constant noise. You can hear the kitchen and it was quite busy. That shouldn't reflect on them though, as that's just my personal preference. 10/10 service experience. Will eat here again."

"Went there. A few days ago and got the pepperoni and the supreme. Pepperoni was great. The people that ate the supreme ranged from average to good. Also had the house salad and the cheese bread. Both of those were good too."

"Theo’s Pizza is locally owned, an immediate plus over any national pizza chain. Simply, Theo’s is just better than one expects! Salads are fresh and plentiful. The various pizzas are made to order with a volume of toppings. You’ll be back time and time again like me."

"Matthew + Lacey gave super friendly service. GREAT lunch special for pizza and drink, they made it like they were making it for themselves. Generous toppings, delicious flavor, and I liked TVs to watch while dining."

"This is the Theo’s closest to me, and my very favorite. The staff is always courteous, hard-working, and on the ball. I often go by myself, order two beers (which I get up front), and when someone brings me my pizza - I’m in seventh heaven… The pizza is always perfect. I am a fan of St. Louis Style pizza (without the provel, of course) and the owners have nailed it. The crust is always crisp, the sauce is slightly sweet, and I always get extra cheese. The specialty pizzas are not to be missed, either! The “Expert” is wonderful, they have a good BBQ pizza, and they do rotate seasonal specials regularly. They also have excellent wings, salads, and sandwiches. The menu isn’t just pizza. And their beer selection - although not huge - is diverse. The drink offerings seem to differ from store to store - this particular one has a couple IPAs on tap that I really enjoy. The only gripe I have is that they haven’t opened a Theo’s closer to me, between Power Blvd and Transcontinental in north Metairie… I will continue to go back again and again. Oh, their customer service is top-notch as well. I hope they stay here forever."