Slice of Chicago

"Some of the worst pizza that we have ever had. We've had better $2 frozen pizzas. This was $50 for two small pizzas and two sodas. We even took the leftover home pizza home and threw it right away. Place is dirty. Ceiling fan is grinding with two burnt out light bulbs. The "clean" high chairs were absolutely filthy. Go to Dominos or Pizza Hut, not here. You've been warned."

"Planning a trip to Sparta or Fort McCoy? This is it. This is the best food in the area, let alone the best pizza! The hand tossed pizza crust is simply delightful, all the goodness of soft pretzel, perfect dipping in the included marinara sauce made with fresh ingredients. And you want to talk options?! I tried just a couple* (check the pics) but the Mac n Cheese has all the cheesy goodness as can be expected in Wisconsin. All the pizzas are honestly just wonderful and you should stop reading reviews and get your butt over here! Atmosphere is cozy! If you're bringing a group larger than 6 please call ahead."

"People tend to whimsically hand out 5-star reviews, especially in smaller towns. This is truly a 5-star pizza place. Had the hand tossed and thin crust and both were great in their own way. Thin was light, crisp and flaky while the hand tossed was something else. The crust has a thin crunchy layer and soft yummy goodness on the inside. Unique in its own right. Truly great."

"Excellent hand crafted pizza. Their marinara sauce is delicious. Try the hand tossed with extra cheese. Don't forget the garlic cheese bread while you're waiting for your pizza. Awesome little setting in an old house."

"Dined In Food: I ordered BBQ Wings and Garlic Cheese Bread. The wings were normal, nothing special. They were luke warm, and took 45 minus to get. They serve with packet salad dressing (Ranch or Bleu Cheese). I think it would be better if they could put in a dipping cup. Garlic Cheese Bread was good. It comes with cold marinara though, major turn off for me. What I can say, is if you are looking for pizza, everyone who was in the resuraunt was raving at how good it was. Speed of Service: Slow. Took 45 minutes to get chicken wings. Every to go order that people came in, was late. The staff was apologizing to every customer. Customer Service: When I walked in, I was never greeted. No one ever even looked at me. Once I asked someone if I could dine in, then they escorted me to a table. The waitress was polite, but never asked me how my food was or came by to refill my drink. But she was polite. Outside thoughts: I like the sign, but the place doesn't scream come in and eat. Inside thoughts: Only seats 25. Four two person tables, and two 6 person tables. Very small. No where for take out order people to sit or stand without getting in the way. Many military accolades on the wall for their support of the restaurant, I love it. Likes: - Simple menu & pizza looked fantastic Dislikes: - Lack of greeting upon entry, and slow service Would I come again: No, put ill order pizza to go"