Elgin Public House

"I enjoyed my food and the atmosphere was good however the portion size left me wanting. I got the fish fry special and with a total bill of 30 dollars with the tip i feel like I should have gotten more. The sides were in condiment cups being just a few bites each i got just enough definitely no way I could have taken any home"

"This was a 5/5 experience. Service was kind and the food was great. There has not been a human soul to eat this well in lifetimes. Unfortunately all the lights are mismatched! It’s jarring and makes the place feel off. Please fix this. I would love to come here all the time if the lightbulbs were like the ones in the center light pictured."

"5/5. Definitely try the Cheese Curds. Everything is delicious and fresh. Service is phenomenal too!"

"Great atmosphere with amazing service. Our waiter made timely rounds and ensured that we were well taken care of. Their cheese curds were a very tasty. The only thing that I didn't like was the chicken strips on my mac n cheese tasted like it was out of a bag. I expected more of a grilled flavor for the price. That doesn't mean that I wouldn't return. I just wouldn't order what I had again."

"I had the pesto chicken sandwich. In my opinion, it needed more pesto. I really couldn't taste it and questioned if they had added it except that I could smell garlic. If there was pesto in the mayonnaise, as the description says, I think it needed more. Nevertheless, I am still giving 5 stars because the sandwich was really good and very flavorful. The chicken was cooked perfectly and topped with thick, high-quality bacon. The pretzel roll was soft and fresh but not doughy. I was also impressed by the sautéed fresh vegetables. They were cooked to a turn and seasoned just right. My husband had the Reuben and Cajun fries. He ate every last morsel. We will definitely be back for future dates."