Old School N.Y. Pizza

"The buffalo chicken pizza was incredibly delicious. Initially, I had some concerns as the pizzas appeared to be old, but the staff promptly brought out a fresh pizza, completely changing my perception. The two young ladies, Ta'Shoni and Koreah, working at the register were courteous and exhibited great patience. My children thoroughly enjoyed the experience of creating their own pizzas. Overall, it was a wonderful experience!"

"I lived in New York, New Jersey, and Philly, so I know a little about good pizza. About 3 years ago I moved to Louisville and literally thought Old School N. Y. was the best around. Well, unfortunately this evening I stopped in to take out a pie, and it is COMPLETE GARBAGE. What happened????? New management????? New head-baker??? HORRIBLE!!! Do NOT waste your good appetite on this junk…. UN-EATABLE"

"Hands down, best New York style pizza outside of New York that I had. It reminds me of NYC after taking a bite. I wish there’s one closer to me in Indy. This will be my go to pizza place from now on when I visit Louisville. The white sauce with tomato and spinach is a must! Stop reading now and order a pizza!"

"I flew into Louisville and went straight to work. After not eating all day, I ordered a pizza and salad. Easy online ordering. As a travel nurse, I've had NY pizza and this pizza was similar. Salad was fine, however, I ordered the cheeseburger pizza which comes with Romano cheese. I have to say, I hate Romano cheese--too sharp for my taste. Unfortunately, although I ordered it without it, they forgot to omit it. I wanted to love the pizza especially since I was starving but I couldn't. I did eat a few pieces and could appreciate the crust, the texture and with the right toppings, I'm sure it's quite wonderful. Regardless of my experience, I will give it another try next time I'm in Louisville. Staff was great, parking was easy. Food was ready when I arrived. Oh, I also had a brownie--it was delicious."

"This place is incredible. We got a calzone and their cheese bread (photo of cheese bread) and it was plenty for the 2 of us. We will definitely be ordering from this spot regularly. The sausage inside of the calzone tastes homemade and is thin slices of a large meatball, perfectly bite sized for a little bit in every bite. The cheese bread is a calzone, stuffed with several different cheeses and is next-level delicious. Their dough is super yummy too. This place stands high above the typical pizza place."