El Arriero Mexican Bar & Grill

"We have eaten here many times in the past. This is a great place to find great Mexican dishes at reasonable prices. Today, our service was not great. We were seated and given chips and salsa. We did not get any menus. We sat there and watched several servers walk by. They were very concerned about clearing tables. We finally had to flag some one down. She said she would find out waiter. A man appears a bit later and drops off some menus. We ordered and ate our food. We did not get the second order of chips we asked for. Server did not check in on our table very often. Again, great place to eat. Today's visit was not up to our expectations."

"It’s good, flavorful food when you’re in the mood for a little Midwest Mexican food! Service is hit or miss- tonight we didn’t get our appetizer, when we told her to just cancel it when she brought out our entrees, she just said, ok… no apology. It was fine, we had plenty of food- it was just a surprise about the nonchalant attitude about our forgotten app. Well definite be back, just sayin…"

"This place is one of the staples when I visit my friend who lives in Warsaw. To date, El Arriero is still the only place I've been able to order a non-"ghost/death/sign a waiver to eat" spicy dish and have it arrive with actual, FLAVORFUL, spice. The Shrimp Diablo is delicious. When it's made spicy, the excess sauce is great on their rice as well. Combine it with fresh chips, absolute heaven on a plate!"

"Food is quality but tortillas aren't made on premises. This is a shame because homemade tortillas will vastly increase the experience and food pleasure. The beef fajitas are a lot but they could do with a bit more flavouring for the meat. Also, the beef fajita meat is chopped very small so you aren't sure what part of the cow you're getting. Otherwise, and including the above, I don't have any complaints, just suggestions to improve the quality of their product. Customer service from the waitstaff is great. The man that sat us and took payment could do with smiling. He was very stern faced. Not angry, just didn't feel like he was approachable."

"We stopped for dinner and we were so disappointed but the homemade guacamole and sangria were fantastic. Service was good too! I ordered fish tacos and the fish was spoiled. So upset! They did take it off the bill. Not sure who the owner is but shame on him! The place is filthy and needs a deep cleaning. The windows are so dirty its hard to see the lake view. The booths are ripped and dirty. Don’t look up! You might get sick!! The ceiling is disgusting. The vent fans have dirt and dust hanging off them and missing ceiling tiles. Tons of Flies in the place which made it so annoying. This could be such a great restaurant!!!"