New Bethel Ordinary

"Staff was super friendly. I ordered a Supreme pizza. If you like more than usual amount of toppings on your pizza this is your spot. I personally like my pizza toppings, cheese, crust ratio to be a bit less so the pizza is consistent. Crust was nice cooked perfectly. If the toppings were cut a bit smaller I think it would have been a home run. Just a bit chunky. But overall great place. Looking forward to trying some other menu options."

"My family came here for a lunch get together. There were 9 adults. We got two of the large pizzas and still took some home! They were amazing! I'm not even exaggerating when I say that the 16“ deluxe pizza was over an inch high with all the toppings they had piled on! The picture just does not do it justice! My nephew works there and my sister says that the incredible pile of toppings is normal there! I ate more than I should and still wanted more it was that good! Also, some people really like a good cheese pull and let me tell ya the cheese pull on both of these pizzas would have mesmerized anyone! Seriously, they should video that and advertise with it! I feel like all the old pizza commercials used to have that, but I never even cared until both the pizzas we got delivered the cinematically perfect cheese pull haha. Anyway, the service was great, the atmosphere during the day was awesome. It was nicely busy without feeling crowded and we could all sit and visit while we ate. Next time I'm in the area, I'll definitely be stopping by."

"So last week I went and grabbed a pizza for dinner and when I got it home and opened it, it was way over cooked. I called back up there and they were already closed so I snapped a pic and went on about my biz. Today I go BACK up there just thinking maybe they had a new oven or cook last week and it was just a little simple mistake/error whatever it happens I understand. I go to the counter and explain to the girl working what happened last week and showed her the pic of the pizza and her exact words were, “omg ya that is def waaay over cooked and left in the oven waaaay too long”. She then asks me if I wanted to place an order and I ordered ANOTHER pizza thinking she was at least minimally going to discount it a little or replace my pizza from last week at no charge. Nope. When my pizza was ready she hands it to me and says have nice day. So then I ask her if there was anything she/they could do about my burnt pizza from last week or are we just goin to act like it’s no big deal and forget about it since she had already charged me full price for the second one and she giggles and says “nope, have a good day” while the other girls behind the counter were laughing. Nope. We wont be back. I’ll take my money and biz on down the road where it’s appreciated and respected."

"Absolutely some of the best pizza I have ever had here in Indianapolis. I ordered this for our luncheon at work. 25 men were fed off of 8 large pies that were party cut - we actually have leftovers and everyone is full!"

"STALE CHIPS on the nachos, topping were very good! Wings were ok Breadsticks are very good if eaten hot Pizza is ok Texas bacon BBQ burger and fries were the best thing we tried here. Mediocre at best Full review to come in next month's magazine!!!"