Casey's 472 East Christmas Boulevard, Santa Claus, IN 47579

"I have no other choice but to give 1 star since I went in for gas & could not get gas. I tried to use 3 differ cards at 2 different pumps but each and every time it would except my payment & everything would work as expected until it would tell me to remove my card. As soon as I removed my card it would say "processing" for FOREVER until I had no other choice but to cancel the transaction. Frustrated, I drove off and got gas somewhere else."

"I stopped to get food after a trip to Holiday World. They were out of most everything, I got wings and they charged me $18 for 16 wings, which I think is ridiculous but prices weren’t posted so shame on me. Then I bought 3 bags of chips clearly labeled for $1.99 per bag. They charged me $2.49. When I complained they yelled at me about how it’s not their fault or problem and there’s nothing they can do about it being mislabeled. Then told me another label was correct (for a different product ) and when I said I wasn’t given that price showed me that it was expired. They then just pulled off the wrong price and said they didn’t have to honor it. I asked to speak to management and Joseph Haynes said that he was the only person there and wouldn’t do anything about it or give me any other contact information."

"I’ve been to so many Casey’s as I am addicted to their coffee lol and this store is by far my best experience at a Casey’s! Stopped by here after visiting Holiday World today and had amazing service! My slice of pizza was hot and fresh and perfectly made, the coffee bar was stocked very well and very clean, over all the store itself was very clean and the staff were very nice, thanks for an amazing experience."

"Everyone is polite, but like most of the Casey’s around here they rarely have any kind of selection of fresh food. Idk, I worked at a Casey’s for a time and the expectation was to have the food stocked consistently. I work on the road and Casey’s used to be a good place to stop for quick, decent food. These days they have too many either slow, inexperienced, or lazy people in all of their kitchens that can’t keep up."

"I purchased 7 burgers from Casey's Friday evening as you can see 4 had the buns burnt so badly they were rock hard. When I tried to return the burgers the kitchen manager came out and without even looking at them told me "that's how they come!" Refused to give me my money back for anything. Ridiculous!"