Panthers Pizza 105 South Locke Street, Nappanee, IN 46550

"We ordered a stuffed crust pizza with pepperoni and it was absolutely delicious! We will definitely order it again! We also ordered an order of cheesy garlic bread. It was ok, but a little too heavily seasoned with oregano."

"Cold, doughy, floppy. Has potential but it was cold and not done underneath. I had to put it back in my oven at home. You can see the wet raw side view"

"never seen pricing like this, they obviously have a very high opinion of themselves, not even the finest pizza in nyc or chi get these prices want a philly steak? base price is 9.99...want 'add ons' like all the ingredients? oh those r xtra! ???! so the 9.99 is for...bread? and everything is outrageously priced. i can literally get 3 lou malnattis deep dish pies delivered by mail on amzn for slightly less. the desserts r off the shelf stuff cut into fourths for 10 a hit 'specialty lg pizza?' how bout 35.00? really? their 'breadsticks' are just pizza w no toppings cut into strips. not authentic italian, not worth the price"

"Great pizza, but after the many years they’ve been in business you’d think they could get a pizza made on time. I was told tonight that my pizza would take an extra 20 min. Forty minutes later it was finally ready. Every time I go here it’s late. I get that it takes a while to make, but then tell your customers it’s actually going to take 1.5 hrs not 40 min when they order. Dining area was also filled with smoke."

"Love their pizza but today I had mine delivered. Ordered 2 pizzas one with just bacon second bacon and mushrooms. I got the 2 topping the second had sausage not bacon. I paid for delivery and was informed that the pizza tipper insists he only put bacon and if I wanted to dispute this to drive my pizza back to them let them be the judge and if they did wrong then I would have to wait to have another one made for me. I already paid 55.74 for 2 pizzas to be delivered and I've been up since 4 am for work it's now 815 pm I'm tired that's why I had it delivered . Nice customer service and standing behind your product."