Open Hearth Lodge 2669 South Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, WI 54234

"Wonderful stay. We visited for one night during a winter storm. So welcoming and comfortable. The guy at the front desk was super friendly and helpful. Our room was spacious, warm, and clean. Free breakfast was spartan, but adequate and served in a cozy nook with natural sunlight and beautiful views. Definitely recommend."

"This place was an absolute gem!!! Such a welcoming and cozy environment. This was my first time here but talking to others staying there who have been lifelong goers, it continues to be an amazing place to stay and continues to be clean, updated, and awesome service. The owner and his daughter were great to interact with. They have a dog designated side of the hotel with fenced in play area. I stayed on the non dog side and never even noticed dogs there! I will be bringing my doggy next time tho! I am so impressed with this place I can’t wait to come back."

"We were very comfortable. Large rooms. Clean and quiet. Pool a bit chilly. Made the hot tub all the more enjoyable. Honor system snack and drinks amazing concept! Sitting by the fire in the lobby relaxing. We had a great visit"

"We can't say enough good things about Open Hearth! We recently stayed here and had a hotel block for our wedding. John and his family were so accommodating and helpful leading up to the weekend and during our stay. He also allowed us to utilize the dining space for "welcome drinks" with guests the night before our wedding, which was so fun and convenient for us. The hotel itself was very nice, cozy, quiet, and clean. We also absolutely LOVED all the amenities for dogs, as our dog is a very important part of our family and also needed to be with us since she was in our wedding. We received so many compliments about the lodge from our guests as well. We'll definitely be back!"

"This was our first time staying at Open Hearth Lodge and we liked it so much we booked it with our family to come next summer. We were impressed with the friendly service at the front desk, especially Tina and John, the owner. The grounds are spacious and beautiful with many amenities to enjoy. The room was clean and towels were easy to obtain by putting a bag outside our room with the used towels to be replaced with clean ones. It was a quiet stay even though the lodge was full. It is dog friendly, at one section of the lodge, and we were never disturbed by them. We highly recommend the Open Hearth and advise a virtual tour on the website."