Penny's Five Star Pizza 1033 4th Avenue, Lake Odessa, MI 48849

"Update: Huge improvement. Got a large pizza this Saturday (2-4-24) and the crust was perfect. Not too thick. Perfect amount of cheese. So happy to have my pizza place back. ♥️ When it’s good, it’s great. I’d rate it as one of the best pizza I’ve ever had. But, the other half of the time is a bummer. Very inconsistent. Lately, the crust has been so thick (at least an inch or more) all the cheese falls to the center and instead of having a whole slice be good, only about half is worth eating and the rest is just raised bread. And it’s not cheap pizza. It’s worth it when it’s made right. Hope they figure out how to fix consistency issues. I’ll give it another try and change my review if the issue is resolved."

"We love Penny's pizza. The garlic butter crust is great. I am back in Michigan about every 4-5 weeks and we make sure we get a pizza at least once. The staff is friendly and pizza is done when they say it will be or before. Subs are good, too, but we opt for the pizza most times."

"We are from out of town and tried their pizza at the concessions during a middle school football game. It was delicious! We drove back the next week to pick up some pizzas, and they went out of their way to make a special pizza we had asked for, not usually offered on the menu. Great customer service and amazing food. We will definitely be back."

"I have been here a few times now. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. They have fantastic pizza! I tried their cheeseburger pizza today, and it was to die for. We will definitely be keeping this in the roatation of places to eat at while in town."

"This place is family owned and very family-oriented I love going to this place everybody's so kind, the food is amazing yes at 5:00 there is a huge rush but it is really worth the wait. Go try the food out and get to love the employees!! They care so much they are willing to even make the bachelorette party a perfect party upon a special request! The food is amazing, The owners are amazing and the people that work there are also amazing. Very yummy desserts that are made from scratch by the owners!!! All kinds of different oatmeal cookies and pies!"