Witmer Wood Tax Consultants, LLC 13631 Leo Road, Leo-Cedarville, IN 46765

"We’ve been with Karen Johnson for many years and can’t believe how thorough she is. We can’t sing her praises enough. She catches our mistakes and pencils them in on our forms. She explains everything very carefully and makes sure we understand before we leave. So grateful we can trust her without wondering if we’re in trouble. WE highly recommend her!!"

"We were clients of theirs for over 10 years. They are supposed to be experts in clergy tax, but that is not evident. One year they made a huge mistake, claiming that we had made a payment worth several hundred dollars when we hadn't. I discovered their mistake when I got an unexpected bill from the IRS. I called them about it and never received any kind of apology for their mistake. Two years ago, I felt like something was wrong with my husband's W-2, so I asked them for advice about it since they are supposedly experts in clergy tax. Julie Wood refused to help me with this issue and was very rude in doing so. This is when we left their firm. We just discovered, after switching to a new accountant, that because of them, we had overpaid on our taxes for all 10 years they prepared our returns. They did not adequately explain things, even when expressly asked for help with a certain line item. I do not recommend Witmer Wood for clergy or any tax payers at all."

"We’re happy and we know it because Karen Johnson at Witmer Wood prepared our 2023 tax returns. She is very knowledgeable and professional…she is a pleasure to work with. This is the second tax year she has prepared our returns. It is well worth the one-hour drive to have her do them. We are so glad we discovered Witmer Wood Tax Consultants. Jane at the front desk is delightful. Overall, great service and excellent value! Barry & Cindy Sisson Warsaw, IN"

"The worst experience I have had with an accountant. Papers repeatedly not filed or filed incorrectly, and when I had to uncover the problems myself and brought it to their attention I was met with hostility and excuses. This did not happen one time it was repeated and never one time did they own their mistake without me having to press them on it. I loved that they claim to be a Christian organization, but their actions were far from that when mistakes happened on their part. I was yelled at over the phone by the owner, after being told repeated she was not available. Suddenly she came on the line very angry at me, when they had tried to pull money from an incorrect business account! I have heard the same thing from others, after I moved on to a fabulous accountant. Save yourself a lot of extra work and find someone else."

"We have used Witmer Wood for the past 12 years in two different states and never had an issue with this firm. I am a Lutheran pastor and they understand the various exemptions and IRS rules for clergy, provide all of the documentation that I need for clergy taxes and they have saved us a bunch of money. When I've had a question they have responded promptly. Their price is fair compared to the other tax firm we used prior to Witmer Wood. We've referred other pastors to them and they've been very happy with this firm."