Key Colony Inn Restaurant & Lounge

"Food Amazing! A lot of locals, but also returning visitors. Food was delicious!"

"There are several negative reviews posted recently, but all of them are from new Google reviewers. I think somebody has it out for this place and is generating fake profiles to lower the ratings. We ate here today and totally enjoyed everything. We had conch chowder, which was so thick with ingredients that the spoon stood up in it. My wife had a fried Mahi burger with two large filets, and I had the grilled Mahi burger that hung over the edges of the bun. There was a huge pile of fries that taste like truffle or double fried. Our server came back several times to make sure we had everything. No problems at all."

"Very disappointed in how little the side dishes are when ordering a dinner. 3 onion rings in my BBQ rib dinner. My friend ordered the New York strip steak which was $36 and it came with just a few French fries. The fried shrimp same thing. Save your money and order from Sparky’s where they actually give you a nice portion and you get full."

"As my week long vacation is coming to an end, we stopped at this restaurant, which is just down the road from where we are staying. I can honestly say, after every single place I have tried so far, this restaurant is my favorite!!! My boyfriend got the filet, and he said it was cooked perfect, but a little dry. Our friend got a shrimp salad and said it was amazing. Our other friend got a burger and said it was great. I got the blackened chicken with a salad, & side of spaghetti, and added a side of spinach, all of it was spectacular. I can’t think of anything that could make my meal better. The portions were big, and prices were very reasonable. Also, the bread that was served before your meal is wonderful and fresh too. Waitress and other staff was super friendly!! I can’t wait to come back! :)"